SAES-422 Multistate Research Activity Accomplishments Report
Sections
Status: Approved
Basic Information
- Project No. and Title: NE1441 : Environmental Impacts of Equine Operations
- Period Covered: 10/01/2018 to 09/30/2019
- Date of Report: 12/03/2019
- Annual Meeting Dates: 08/19/2019 to 08/21/2019
Participants
Robin Brumfeld (Rutgers) Mike Westendorf (Rutgers) Mark Reiger (UDEL) Masoud Hashimi (UMASS) Jennifer Weinert (Rutgers) Krishona Martinson (UMN) Danielle Smarsh (PSU) Laura Kenny (PSU) Amy Burk (UMD) Carey Williams (Rutgers) Mieke Holder (UKY - on line, both days), Carissa Wickens (UFL – on line, Tues.)
The following individuals made presentation at the meeting:
- Mike Westendorf (Rutgers)
- Jennifer Weinert (Rutgers)
- Carey Williams (Rutgers)
- Robin Brumfield (Rutgers)
- Masoud Hashimi (UMASS)
- Krishona Martinson (UMN)
- Danielle Smarsh (PSU)
- Laura Kenny (PSU)
- Amy Burk (UMD)
- Mieke Holder (UKY - on line, both days)
- Carissa Wickens (UFL – on line, Tues.)
The following are some of the important areas of work during this meeting:
Forage Work
- The comparison of diffferent turfgrass cultivars, including cool-season and warm-season varieties, is being studied at several universities.
- The use of grazing muzzles and their effect on stress and the welfare of horses.
- Hay storage methods for round bales is being compared.
- Stockpiling of forages for fall and winter feeding.
- Comparing the use of novel warm-season grasses, eg. crabgrass for summer feeding.
- Testing a chewing sensor to monitor grazing behavior to help determine forage intake and animal behavior.
- Compare grass legume mixtures that include a perennial peanut. The horses seem to avoid it.
- Extending of the grazing season using annual grasses such as crabgrass in the summer and forage stockpiling for feeding in the fall and winter.
Composting and Manure Disposal
- Compost at equine stock facilities to characterize nutrient profile and potential for leachate. Very little nutrient runoff was found on structures with covers and impervious surfaces.
- Antibiotic resistance in horse manure. How can it be quantified? Follow the dairy industry as a model.
- Equine carcass composting to educate horse owners and professionals on the process and benefits, as well as the analysis for chemical compostion of compost.
Trace Mineral Research
- Study the presence of heavy metals in animal feeds: What does it mean for the horse that outlives most other livestock species, and the environment.
- Hair analysis.
- Excessive levels of dietary mineral supplementation (beyond nitrogen and phosphorus) that influence trace minerals and water quality.
Outreach
- On-farm pasture programs including pasture walks for soil testing, plant and weed ID, poisonous plants, and pasture evaluation, etc.
- Farm visits.
- Environmental Friendly Farm Program.
- Horse Forum (Maryland) – Environmental Stewardship Discussion, BMP into public equestrian facilities, zoning laws restricting the number of horses per acre, land use for equestrian purposes always viewed as AG.
- On line certificate courses, on-line composting school.
Accomplishments
Accomplishment 1: Forages for Horses
Outcomes: Extending the grazing season
Outputs: Development of different grazing strategies
- Use of warm season grasses to provide increased summer grazing
- Stockpiling of fall forages from cool-season grasses to lengthen the fall/winter grazing season
- Use of cover crops including the use of small grains such as rye or wheat for fall forage accumulation
- Comparison of forage varieties
- Comparison of fertilization strategies
- Improving hay quality for winter use
Activities: Research productivity
- Comparison of grass legume mix pasture for horses using a perennial peanut perennial peanut (fixes nitrogen and grows close to the ground), bahaigrass (fertilized and not) and compared forage yield and quality, botanical composition, horse performance (digestibility of each, blood samples for glucose and insulin, body weight, BCS, body fat), N inputs, environmental impact (reducing off farm nitrogen), weekly measures, temporary fencing to allow similar herbage allowance. Horses avoided the perennial peanut and do not graze it.
2. Different grass cultivars are being compared.
- Incorporating novel warm season grasses into cool season grazing.
- 8 cool-season varieties, 6 warm-season varieties compared, Regenerate and Maestro Tall fescue most tolerant cool-seasons, but both have endophyte, creeping bentgrass lowest NSC, but lowest persistence.
- Warm-season Compadre and Zenith zoyiagrass, most wear tolerant, moderate yield, average NSC, Red River crabgrass and common bermudagrass were least tolerant
- Palatability of Turfgrasses, no difference in cool-season, common bermudagrass and crabgrass most preferred (however least tolerant)
- Extension of the grazing season using annuals such as crabgrass.
- Planting a couple varieties of forage oats for fall/winter grazing; plan to run weanlings and yearlings on the oats.
- Stockpiling research, species selection, tall fescue traditionally, also looking into orchard grass, monoculture and mixed, studying fertility and nitrogen rate and timing upon yield.
3. Planting winter rye and oats to extend the grazing season and hope to graze further into the fall.
- Hay bale wrap trial – B-wrap, net wrap, and twine effects on both alfalfa and low lignin alfalfa. After one-year of storage with every 3 months bale weight and hay sampling, B-wrap did not increase in moisture, low lignin alfalfa stayed low for first 6 months, thereafter no difference. No loss of dry matter over one-year with B-wrap. After 90 days it pays to use B-wrap. B-wrap had very low mold and yeast levels. Fed to cattle to do a preference trial, used 18 cow/calf pairs.
- Grazing muzzles compared on the stress and welfare of horses: no muzzle, 10 hrs/d and 24 hrs/d. 10 hrs/d did not control weight gain, voluntary exercise during the day did not change, 24 hrs/d group had lower Heart Rate and higher Heart Rate Variability.
- Other projects:
- Implementing a chew-sensor technology as a grazing tool – RumiWatch system (Itin + Hoch, GmbH). Equine version is EquiWatch, validated with forage vs. concentrate, agreement with chewing was 99%, not validated with grazing. Validating with chewing activity and applying it to grazing. Pilot project using the EquiWatch halters looking at ad libitum hay vs. pasture grazing, showed longer grazing time with pasture and a strong pattern with grazing being higher at the mid-afternoon time.
- Comparing glucose and insulin response to horses on warm and cool season grasses; warm season grasses will have lower Non-Structural Carbohydrates because they do not store fructans. Glucose area under the curve was lower when grazing warm season grass particularly with the crabgrass, glucose did correlate positively with Non-Structural Carbohydrates, insulin didn’t differ with forage variety.
- Studying a hand-held NIR (Near Infrared Reflectance Spectroscopy) unit for on taking sample analysis and comparing to wet chemistry
Milestones:
- Work to extend grazing season has resulted in collaborative research between nearly all states involved in the project.
- Use of warm-season grasses is a potentially valuable summer forage option.
- Crabgrass has promise as a summer forage.
Accomplishment 2: Composting and Manure Disposal
Activities:
- Equine Carcass Composting: preliminary work completed by Mark Hutchinson from Maine. Using 4 chemically euthanized horses, carcasses are being composted for 6 months. In addition to analyzing for chemical composition of the compost, horse owners and professionals are being educated on the process and benefits. This particular project is being conducted at the University of Minnesota; previous work has been completed at the University of Maine.
Accomplishment 3: Outreach
Activities:
- On-farm programs including pasture walks, pasture evaluation, soil testing, forage testing, plant and weed identification, and poisonous plant discussions have taken place at most of the states.
- Extension programs about feed management, manure management, and composting have also taken place at some of the states.
- In addition, horse owner field days, e-newsletters, webinars, websites, Face Book pages, YouTube channels, Mobil Aps, Infographics, and horse conferences were conducted at most states.
Milestones:
- Environmentally Friendly Farm program (Pennsylvania) including farm evaluation and multiple agencies.
- Environmental Stewardship Discussion (Maryland Horse Forum), BMP's in public equestrian facilities.
- On-line certificate courses (Minnesota).
- Online composting course (New Jersey).
Impacts
- Composting • Equine Carcass Composting, using 4 chemically euthanized horses composted for 6 months to education horse owners and professionals on the value of carcass composting. Outputs include Field Days and Infographics and other materials. Initial results indicate the project is successful and will prove a good educational program. • Compost program at Equine Stock Facilities, characterize nutrient profiles and the potential for leachate. There is little nutrient runoff on structures with covers and impervious surfaces.
- Extending the grazing season: The projects that have been done this year to further research and education with pasture has been to develop different grazing strategies to help lengthen the grazing season in both the north and the southern U.S. Some of these projects include: Using warm season grasses to provide increased summer grazing in the Northeast, using cool-season grasses in the winter in the southern region to extend the grazing season, stockpiling of fall forages from cool-season grasses to lengthen the fall/winter grazing season, using of cover crops including the use of small grains such as rye or wheat for fall forage accumulation, comparing forage varieties for the health of the horse and a horses grazing preference, comparing fertilization strategies, and improving hay quality for winter use when grazing is not available. More specifics on the research activities include: • A comparison of grass legume mix pasture for horses using a perennial peanut perennial peanut (fixes nitrogen and grows close to the ground), bahaigrass (fertilized and not) and compared forage yield and quality, botanical composition, horse performance (digestibility of each, blood samples for glucose and insulin, body weight, BCS, body fat), N inputs, environmental impact (reducing off farm nitrogen), weekly measures, temporary fencing to allow similar herbage allowance. Horses avoided the perennial peanut and do not graze it. • Different grass cultivars are being compared across the country and in different regions, by incorporating novel warm season grasses into cool season grazing. • 8 cool-season varieties, 6 warm-season varieties compared: Regenerate and Maestro Tall fescue were the most tolerant cool-season varieties, but both have endophyte, where creeping bentgrass was the lowest NSC, but also had the lowest persistence. Warm-season grasses, Compadre and Zenith zoyiagrass were the most wear tolerant, with moderate yield, and average NSC, where Red River crabgrass and common bermudagrass were least tolerant. The palatability of Turfgrasses showed no difference in cool-season varieties, however Common Bermudagrass and Crabgrass were the most preferred but least tolerant. • The extension of the grazing season in New Jersey was investigated using warm-season annuals such as crabgrass. The project found that horses preferred crabgrass similarly to the cool-season mix pasture that is typically planted. Crabgrass had higher sward height and yield in the hot summer months compared to cool-season mixed pastures. Crabgrass planted integrated into a cool-season pasture also works well and might be the best production recommendation for farmers. • Stockpiling research focused on species selection and found that tall fescue traditionally is used but the study also looked into orchard grass in monoculture and mixed. Also studied fertility and nitrogen rate and timing upon yield. • Another trial investigated the use of various hay bale wraps (B-wrap, net wrap, and twine) and its effects on both alfalfa and low lignin alfalfa. After one-year of storage with samples every 3 months for bale weight and hay nutrients the B-wrap did not increase in moisture, and the low lignin alfalfa stayed low for first 6 months, thereafter no difference. There was also no loss of dry matter over one-year with B-wrap. In the end it is recommended that after 90 days it pays to use B-wrap because it had very low mold and yeast levels. • Another study compared on the stress and welfare of horses when using a grazing muzzle. There were treatments of no muzzle, 10 hrs/d and 24 hrs/d. The group with the muzzle on 10 hrs/d did not control weight gain, and voluntary exercise during the day did not change. The group with the muzzle on 24 hrs/d had lower heart rate and higher heart rate variability, both which indicate lower levels of stress compared to the group wearing the muzzle for only 10 hrs/d. • A New Jersey study is implementing a chew-sensor technology as a grazing tool (RumiWatch system [Itin + Hoch, GmbH]). Equine version is EquiWatch, validated with forage vs. concentrate, agreement with chewing was 99%, however it has never been validated with grazing horses. The validation of the EquiWatch version with chewing activity when grazing highly correlated and therefore is a valid tool to use when performing grazing studies to show number of bites and chews, and grazing duration in horses. Apilot project using the EquiWatch system looked at ad libitum hay vs. pasture grazing and showed longer grazing time with pasture and a strong pattern with grazing being higher at the mid-afternoon time. • Another study compared glucose and insulin response to horses on warm and cool season grasses; warm season grasses will have lower Non-Structural Carbohydrates because they do not store fructans. Glucose area under the curve was lower when grazing warm season grass particularly with the crabgrass, glucose did correlate positively with Non-Structural Carbohydrates, insulin didn’t differ with forage variety. Overall the take home message is: 1. Work to extend grazing season has resulted in collaborative research between nearly all states involved in the project. 2. Use of warm-season grasses is a potentially valuable summer forage option. 3. Crabgrass has promise as a summer forage both for increasing summer grazing and for lower non-structural carbohydrate varieties for horses sensitive to soluble carbohydrates.
Publications
Bowman, M.A., Pratt-Phillips, S.E., Siciliano, P.D. 2019. Effect of restricting time allowed for grazing on fecal microbiome. J. Equine Vet. Sci. 76:78.
Bowman, M.A., Pratt-Phillips, S.E., Siciliano, P.D. 2019. Effect of an abrupt diet change on the fecal microbiome. J. Equine Vet. Sci. 76:74-75.
Catalano, D.N., B.J. Heins, S. Missaghi, M.R. Hathaway, and K.L. Martinson+. 2019. The Effect of Goldfish (Carassius auratus) on Water Quality in Horse Stock Tanks. J. of Equine Vet. Sci. 79: 73-78.
Catalano, D.N., C.C. Sheaffer, A.M. Grev, M.L. DeBoer and K.L. Martinson+. 2019. Yield, Forage Nutritive Value, and Preference of Legumes under Horse Grazing. Agronomy J. 111: 1,312-1,322.
DeBoer, M.L., M.R. Hathaway, K.J. Kuhle, P.S.D. Weber, C.C. Sheaffer and K.L. Martinson+. 2018. Glucose and insulin response of horses grazing alfalfa, perennial cool-season grass, and teff during the spring and late-fall. J. of Equine Vet. Sci. 72: 108-111.
DeBoer, M., K. Martinson+, K. Kuhle, C. Sheaffer and M. Hathaway. 2018. Plasma amino acid concentrations of horses grazing alfalfa, cool-season perennial grasses and teff. J. of Equine Vet. Sci. 72: 72-78.
DeBoer, M.L., M.R. Hathaway, K.J. Kuhle, P.S.D. Weber, A.S. Reiter, C.C. Sheaffer, M.S. Wells and K.L. Martinson+. 2018. Glucose and insulin response of horses grazing alfalfa, perennial cool-season grass, and teff across seasons. J. Equine Vet. Sci. 68: 33-38.
Jaqueth*, A.L., T.R. Turner, Iwaniuk, M.E., B.J. McIntosh, and A.O. Burk. 2019. Relative traffic tolerance of cool-season turfgrasses and suitability for grazing by equine. J. Equine Vet. Sci. 78:79-88. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jevs.2019.04.005.
Jaqueth, A.L., M. Hathaway, D.N. Catalano, N.C. Linders, R. Mottet and K.L. Martinson+. Using web-based surveys to explore equine industry practices and future research needs. Accepted for publication in the Journal of Equine Veterinary Science on October 28, 2019.
Mottet, R.S., R.D Moon, M.R. Hathaway and K.L. Martinson+. 2018. Effectiveness of Stable Fly Protectants on Adult Horses. J. Equine Vet. Sci. 69: 11-15.
Weinert, J. R. and C. A. Williams. 2018. Recovery of pasture forage production following winter rest in continuous and rotational horse grazing systems. J. Equine Vet. Sci. 70:32-37. doi.org/10.1016/j.jevs.2018.06.017
Williams, C. A., L. B. Kenny, and A. O. Burk. 2019. Effects of grazing system, season, and forage carbohydrates on glucose and insulin dynamics of the grazing horse. J. Anim. Sci. 97:2541–2554. doi: 10.1093/jas/skz103NIFA
Book Chapters
Kenny, L. B., A. O. Burk, and C. A. Williams. 2019. Managing equine grazing for pasture productivity. In: Horse Pasture Management, edited by P. Sharpe. Academic Press, London, UK. pp. 141-155. doi: 10.1016/B978-0-12-812919-7.00009-3
Kenny, L. B., M. Westendorf, and C. A. Williams. 2019. Managing manure, erosion, and water quality in and around horse pastures. In: Horse Pasture Management, edited by P. Sharpe. Academic Press, London, UK. pp. 245-259. doi:10.1016/B978-0-12-812919-7.00014-7
Westendorf, M. L., C. A. Williams, S. Murphy, and L. B. Kenny. 2019. Generation and Management of Manure from Horses and other Equids. In: Animal Manure: Production, Characteristics, Environmental Concerns and Management. edited by H. M. Waldrip, P. H. Pagliari, and Z. He. ASA-SSSA-CSSA, Special Publications, Madison, WI. (in press). pp. 1-19. doi:10.2134/asaspecpub67.c8
Conference Papers
Powlowski, C., J. Weinert, and C. A. Williams. 2018. Forage recovery in rotational vs continuous pasture systems after intensive horse grazing. Mid-Atlantic Nutr. Conf. Proc. 16 (https://ansc.umd.edu/extension/mid-atlantic-nutrition-conference/past-proceedings).
Weinert, J. and C. A. Williams. 2019. Glucose and insulin responses of horses grazing integrated warm- and cool-season grass rotational pasture systems. J. Equine Vet. Sci. 76:103. Abstract #140.
Weinert, J., J. Werner, and C. A. Williams. 2019. Implementation of a chew-sensor based technology as a tool for equine grazing research. J. Equine Vet. Sci. 76:91-92. Abstract #114
Williams, C. A., K. Sullivan, and L. B. Kenny. 2019. Effects of twenty-seven months of rotational vs. continuous grazing on horse and pasture condition. J. Equine Vet. Sci. 76:102-103. Abstract #139.
Williams, C. A., K. Sullivan, and L. B. Kenny. 2019. Effects of twenty-seven months of rotational vs. continuous grazing on horse and pasture condition. J. Equine Vet. Sci. 76:102-103. Abstract #139.
Extension Bulletin
Booklet. Manure Management Training Manual for Equine Farmers. Rutgers Cooperative Extension and the New Jersey Agricultural Experiment Station, The USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service and the Rutgers University Equine Science Center.
Popular Press
Burk, A.O. 2018. Ten Steps to a Healthy Productive Pasture. The Equiery. April Issue.