NC_old1198: Renewing an Agriculture of the Middle: Value Chain Design, Policy Approaches, Environmental and Social Impacts
(Multistate Research Project)
Status: Inactive/Terminating
Date of Annual Report: 10/22/2012
Report Information
Period the Report Covers: 10/01/2012 - 10/01/2012
Participants
Contained in minutesBrief Summary of Minutes
Please see attached minutesAccomplishments
Not applicable for this first meetingPublications
Not applicable for this first meetingImpact Statements
- Not applicable for this meeting
Date of Annual Report: 03/11/2014
Report Information
Period the Report Covers: 10/01/2012 - 09/01/2013
Participants
Mary Ahearn, USDA/ERS, mahearn@ers.usda.gov;J. Gordon Arbuckle, Jr., Iowa - Iowa State University (IOW), arbuckle@iastate.edu;
Carmen Bain, Iowa - Iowa State University (IOW), cbain@iastate.edu;
Christy A Brekken, OTHER-Oregon State University, brekkenc@onid.orst.edu;
Larry L Burmeister, OTHER-Ohio University, burmeist@ohio.edu;
Kate Clancy, OTHER-Independent Food Systems Consultant, klclancy@comcast.net;
David S. Conner, Vermont - University of Vermont (VT.), david.conner@uvm.edu;
Kathryn De Master, California -Berkeley : University of California, Berkeley (CALB), kathryn.demaster@berkeley.edu;
Michael D. Duffy, Iowa - Iowa State University (IOW), mduffy@iastate.edu;
Gail W Feenstra, University of California-Davis (CALB), gwfeenstra@ucdavis.edu;
Alicia Fisher, OTHER-University of Kentucky, alicia.fisher@uky.edu;
Charles A Francis, Nebraska - University of Nebraska (NEB), cfrancis2@unl.edu;
Thomas W. Gray, USDA, thomas.gray@wdc.usda.gov;
Lauren E Gwin, OTHER-Oregon State University, lauren.gwin@oregonstate.edu;
Shermain Hardesty, University of California-Davis, shermain@primal.ucdavis.edu;
Clare Hinrichs, Pennsylvania - Pennsylvania State (PEN), Agricultural Economics, Sociology, and Education, chinrichs@psu.edu;
Jan Joannides, OTHER-University of Minnesota, joann001@umn.edu;
Robert King, Minnesota - University of Minnesota (MIN), Applied Economics, rking@umn.edu;
Fred Kirschenmann, Iowa - Iowa State University (IOW), Leopold Center, leopold1@iastate.edu;
William Lacy, California -Davis : University of California, Davis (CALB), Human and Community Development, wblacy@ucdavis.edu;
Daniel A. Lass, Massachusetts - University of Massachusetts (MAS), Resource Economics, dan.lass@resecon.umass.edu;
Larry S. Lev, Oregon Cooperative Extension (ORE), Agricultural and Resource Economics, larry.lev@oregonstate.edu;
Marcia Ostrom, Washington - Washington State University (WN.P), WA Co-op Extension / Ctr for Sus. Ag & Nat. Res., mrostrom@wsu.edu;
Hikaru Peterson, Kansas - Kansas State university (KAN), hhp@agecon.ksu.edu;
George (Steve) Stevenson, Wisconsin - University of Wisconsin (WIS), gstevenson@mailplus.wisc.edu;
Keiko Tanaka, Kentucky - University of Kentucky (KY.), Community and Leadership Development, ktanaka@uky.edu;
Michelle R Worosz, Alabama - Auburn University (ALA), Ag Econ & Rural Sociology, michelle_worosz@auburn.edu;
Zhaohui Wu, OTHER-Oregon State University , wuz@bus.oregonstate.edu;
Tal Yifat, OTHER-University of Chicago, tal@uchicago.edu;
Brief Summary of Minutes
Brief summary of annual meeting:Date: October 15-16, 2013
Location:
Campus Club in Memorial Union, University of Minnesota
300 Washington Ave. SE, Minneapolis, MN 55455
Attendance:
Christy Anderson Brekken (OSU), Larry Burmeister, Kate Clancy, David Conner, Gail Feenstra, Alicia Fisher (UKY), Lauren Gwin, Shermain Hardesty, Jan Joannides, Rob King, Fred Kirschenmann, Larry Lev, Michelle Miller (UW, replacing Steve Stevenson), Marcy Ostrom, Hikaru Peterson, Keiko Tanaka, Zaohui Wu, Tal Yifat
General Project Discussion:
As seen by the list of various outputs from the group members, the state project group members individually had a productive year. There were a few new members to the group, which later led to a lively discussion on what the Ag of the Middle is and the multi-state project groups identity. It was also important that two AFRI proposals were generated from the discussion from the 2012 annual meetings, in efforts to offer collaborative opportunities among members to further the project objectives.
We had a productive discussion on the Ag of the Middle website (http://agofthemiddle.org/), which was initially developed by a coordinating committee of the Ag of the Middle initiative. The site had been managed by the Center for Integrated Agricultural Systems (CIAS) at UW Madison, affiliated with one of the coordinating committee members. The coordinating committee was officially dissolved in May 2013. The multi-state project group agreed that the web site is invaluable outlet for the projects activities and outputs on Ag of the Middle. A sub-committee was formed to work with the communication manager at the CIAS on redesign and update content.
Another sub-committee was formed to pursue the idea of organizing a symposium/conference co-hosted by multiple professional associations to feature the project work on Ag of the Middle. In addition to the two primary associations of the attending members, the sub-committee explored the idea of reaching out to other professional and disciplinary associations who address issues of food systems.
A third small group discussed ideas of sharing teaching resources on the topics pertinent to Ag of the Middle and other food systems issues. Their activity will depend largely on whether the member-only access can be created on the Ag of the Middle website. Group members outside the small group showed interest in contributing to the effort.
Two other topics discussed by all attendees were on the policy update and funding opportunities outside the federal government, which was shut down during the meeting. We discussed how as individuals affiliated with academic institutions we can voice our concerns to proposed policies such as the Food Safety Modernization Act. Members shared their knowledge of various non-governmental funding agencies. The discussion led to how we should promote the project/group to these agencies. We agreed that we should continue discussing how to reach out to these private/non-profit agencies with the importance of the work on Ag of the Middle, as we successfully made inroads to the land-grant and the USDA.
Lastly, each member identified which NC-1198 project objective his/her work contributes most and discussed accomplishments and directions for the coming year. The group consisting of members contributing to the economic objective discussed how to use the Food Systems Indicator developed by King effectively in research and outreach activities and to illustrate the current state of the Ag of the Middle. Only two members were primarily working on the labor and community objective; they were co-authoring a working paper. No member was currently engaged in activities addressing the environmental objective, but the activities were proposed in the AFRI grant proposal on impacts on farmers. Even if the proposal is not funded in the current round, the PIs agreed to pursue the idea in some way. Another large group discussed their work on the policy objective. The group agreed that they have identified research questions on existing policies but have not examined the optimal designs/alterations of policies and programs to enhance future performance of Ag of the Middle entities.
Accomplishments
Accomplishments - October 2012 to September 2013:<br /> <br /> Outputs:<br /> <br /> Activities: <br /> <br /> Grants Submitted by members<br /> <br /> Peterson, H.H., G.W. Feenstra, S.D. Hardesty, M.R. Ostrom, K. Tanaka, C. Anderson-Brekken, and A.M. Fisher. Impacts of Values-Based Supply Chains on Small and Medium-Sized Farms. 2014-2017. Submitted to the USDA-AFRI, Small & Medium-Size Farms Priority area. Under review.<br /> <br /> Lev, L., R. King, J. Joannides, G. Feenstra, S. Hardesty. Cultivating Specialty Food Industry Sales: New Opportunities for Small and Medium-Sized Farms. Submitted to the USDA-AFRI, Small & Medium-Size Farms Priority area. Under review.<br /> <br /> Lass, D., and D. Conner. Farmer Profitability in the New England Farm to Institution Market: Impacts of Transaction Costs and Market Structure. 2014-2017. Lass, PI; Conner co-PI. Submitted to USDA-AFRI. Under review. This project would measure farmer willingness to engage in institutional markets, identify opportunities and barriers and design educational and outreach materials.<br /> <br /> Stephenson, G., and L. Gwin. Beyond Direct: Asessing the Potential of Local and Regional Wholesale Markets to Enhance Farmer Prosperity. Submitted to the USDA-AFRI, Small & Medium-Size Farms Priority area. Under review.<br /> <br /> Grants and Awards Received by members<br /> <br /> Social-Economic Dimensions of the Nutrient Reduction Strategy. Cathy Kling, Lois Wright Morton, and J. Gordon Arbuckle Jr. $116,000. Iowa Nutrient Research Center. 2013-2014.<br /> <br /> Developing an Integrated Management and Communication Plan for Sudden Death Syndrome. D. Mueller, L. Leandro, J. Arbuckle, C. Bradley, M. Chilvers, S. Cianzio, J. Faghihi, A. Fakhoury, V. Ferris, G. Hartman, D. Malvick, A. Tenuta, G. Tylka, and K. Wise. $500,000. North Central Soybean Research Program. 2013 2015.<br /> <br /> Mary Harris (PI), Matt Helmers, (PI), J. Gordon Arbuckle Jr. (Co-PI), Matt Liebman, Matt ONeal, Lisa Schulte-Moore, and John Tyndall. Facilitation of Multipurpose Prairie STRIPs Adoption by Iowa Farmers. $52,511. Iowa State Soil Conservation Committee R&D Grant Program. 2012-2013.<br /> <br /> J. Gordon Arbuckle Jr. (Co-PI) and Edward Cox. Sustainable Agricultural Land Tenure and Risk Management for Extreme Climatic Events. $46,299. Leopold Center for Sustainable Agriculture. 2/1/2013 to 1/31/2014.<br /> <br /> Lisa Schulte-Moore (PI), J. Gordon Arbuckle Jr. (Co-PI), Kristi Franz, Emily Heaton, Matt Helmers, Kirsten Hofmokel, Tom Isenhart, Matt Liebman, and John Tyndall. Integrating Project Knowledge, Land Use Scenarios, and InVest Modeling: The Next Step in Developing a Payment for Ecosystem Services Scheme for the Big Creek Watershed. $35,460. Leopold Center for Sustainable Agriculture. 2/1/2013 to 1/31/2014.<br /> <br /> Fostering sustainable livestock production in Vermont: prospects for value chain partnerships. Vermont Agricultural Experiment Station, 2012-2014. (Conner, PI). $34,905 Peer-reviewed by internal UVM panel. This project measures the preponderance of value chain partnerships in the VT livestock sector.<br /> <br /> Feenstra, G. Davis Farm-to-School Evaluation, from Yolo Farm to Fork. SAREP will evaluate outcomes of the Davis Farm-to-School Program, particularly the extent to which DJUSD increases farm fresh food for school lunch. SAREP contract: $6,690 for 6/1/13 12/31/13.<br /> <br /> Feenstra, G. Capitalizing on new values-based marketing channels: Using market tours to link small, beginning, and immigrant producers with wholesale buyers, Gift from Farm Credits. ASI/SAREP award: $60,000 for 7/13-6/14.<br /> <br /> Feenstra, G. Yolo County Farm to School Planning and Implementation: Evaluation, from Yolo County (part of their CDFA funded project). SAREP will evaluate program components. ASI/SAREP award: $60,000 for 10/12 6/15.<br /> <br /> Grant Proposals Submitted, not Funded<br /> <br /> Takle, E.S., C. Anderson, J.G. Arbuckle, W.J. Gutowski, M.J. Helmers, T.G. Johnson, C.M Ammann, J. Delmuth, H. Lazrus. Midwest Integrated Sciences and Assessments (MISA): An Innovation Space for Decision Making. Submitted to NOAA, April 2013. $3,536,742. Not Funded.<br /> <br /> Milestones:<br /> <br /> We currently have a few existing collaborations among the members and many activities with members collaborating with colleagues outside the NC-1198 project. Successful outcomes of the grants generated by discussions from the 2012 annual meeting and changes to the Ag of the Middle website will be milestones looking ahead.<br />Publications
Arbuckle, J. Gordon Jr. 2013. Farmer support for extending Conservation Compliance beyond soil erosion: Evidence from Iowa. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 68(2): 99-109.<br /> <br /> Arbuckle, J. Gordon Jr. 2013. Farmer attitudes toward proactive targeting of agricultural conservation programs. Society & Natural Resources 26:625-641.<br /> <br /> Arbuckle, J. Gordon Jr. 2013. Clean Water State Revolving Fund Loans and Landowner Investments in Agricultural Best Management Practices in Iowa. Journal of the American Water Resources Association 49(1): 67-75.<br /> <br /> Arbuckle, J. Gordon Jr., Lois Wright Morton, and Jon Hobbs. 2013. Understanding Farmer Perspectives on Climate Change Adaptation and Mitigation: The Roles of Trust in Sources of Climate Information, Climate Change Beliefs, and Perceived Risk. Environment and Behavior. doi:10.1177/0013916513503832<br /> <br /> Arbuckle, J. Gordon Jr., Patti Cale-Finnegan, and Tony Toigo. 2013. Applied Social Science Research to Improve Water Quality Programming: Participatory Evaluation of Iowas Clean Water State Revolving Fund Program. Water Resources Impact 15(2): 3-5.<br /> <br /> Arbuckle, J. Gordon Jr., Lois Wright Morton, and Jon Hobbs. 2013. Farmer beliefs and concerns about climate change and attitudes toward adaptation and mitigation: Evidence from Iowa. Climatic Change. 118:551563. DOI 10.1007/s10584-013-0700-0.<br /> <br /> Arbuckle, J. Gordon Jr., Linda Stalker Prokopy, Tonya Haigh, Jon Hobbs, Tricia Knoot, Cody Knutson, Adam Loy, Amber Saylor Mase, Jean McGuire, Lois Wright Morton, John Tyndall, Melissa Widhalm. 2013. Climate Change Beliefs, Concerns, and Attitudes toward Adaptation and Mitigation among Farmers in the Midwestern United States. Climatic Change Letters. DOI 10.1007/s10584-013-0707-6.<br /> <br /> Becot, F., Nickerson, V., Conner, D. & Kolodinsky, J. 2012. Costs of Food Safety Certification on Fresh Produce Farms in Vermont. HortTechnology, 22(5). 705-714.<br /> <br /> Buckley, J., Conner, D., Matts, C. and Hamm, M. Social relationships and farm-to-institution initiatives: complexity and scale in local food systems. Journal of Hunger and Environmental Nutrition (Accepted for publication May 6 2013).<br /> <br /> Campbell, D., I. Carlisle-Cummins and G. Feenstra. Community food systems: Strengthening the research to practice continuum. Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems and Community Development, Vol 3(3). [http://www.agdevjournal.com/volume-3-issue-3/343-community-food-systems.html?catid=133%3Aopen-call-papers].<br /> <br /> Clancy, K. 2013. Values-based food supply chains: Program participation and policy challenges. CIAS, University of Wisconsin.<br /> <br /> Conner, D., Izumi, B., Liquori, T. and Hamm, M. 2012. Sustainable School Food Procurement in Large K-12 Districts: Prospects for Value Chain Partnerships. Agricultural and Resource Economics Review 41 (1): 100113.<br /> <br /> Conner, D. Institutional Food Service. In P.B. Thompson and D.M. Kaplan (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Agricultural and Food Ethics [in press].<br /> <br /> Feenstra, G. and D. Campbell. Local and regional food systems. In P.B. Thompson and D.M. Kaplan (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Agricultural and Food Ethics [in press]. <br /> <br /> Gwin, L., A. Thiboumery, R. Stillman. 2013. Local Meat and Poultry Processing: the Importance of Business Commitments for Long-Term Viability. Washington, DC: USDA Economic Research Service.<br /> <br /> Gwin, L. and A. Thiboumery. 2013. Local Meat Processing: Business Strategies and Policy Angles. Vermont Law Review (June).<br /> <br /> Hardesty, S., G. Feenstra, T. Lerman, D. Visher, D. Thilmany-McFadden, A. Gunter, T. Gilpatrick and G. Nurse. In press- 2014 (should go online any day nowsee OnLine First at http://edq.sagepub.com/. Values-based Supply Chains: Supporting Regional Food and Farms. Economic Development Quarterly.<br /> <br /> Hinrichs, C. Clare. 2013. Regionalizing food security? Imperatives, intersections and contestations in a post-9/11 world. Journal of Rural Studies 29: 7-18.<br /> <br /> Hinrichs, Clare and Liz Charles. 2012. Local food systems and networks in the US and the UK: Community development considerations for rural areas. Pp. 156-176 in Rural Transformations and Rural Policies in the UK and US, edited by M. Shucksmith, D. Brown, S. Shortall, J. Vergunst and M. Warner. New York: Routledge.<br /> <br /> King, Robert P. and G.W Stevenson. 2013. Values-Based Food Supply Chains: Co-op Partners Warehouse. http://www.cias.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/cooppartnersfinal061313.pdf<br /> <br /> King, Robert P., Larry Lev, and Marcia Ostrom. 2013. Using Values-Based Food Supply Chain Case Studies in University Classes. http://www.cias.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/valuechainunivclassfinal082913.pdf<br /> <br /> Lev, L.; G.W. Stevenson. 2013. Values-based food supply chains: An introduction to nine case studies. CIAS, University of Wisconsin. <br /> <br /> Lev, L.; G.W. Stevenson. 2013. Values-based food supply chains: Shepherds Grain. CIAS, University of Wisconsin.<br /> <br /> Morton, Lois Wright, Jon Hobbs, and J. Gordon Arbuckle Jr. 2013. Shifts in Farmer Uncertainty Over Time About Sustainable Farming Practices and Modern Farmings Reliance on Commercial Fertilizers, Insecticides and Herbicides. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation 68(1): 1-12.<br /> <br /> Ostrom, M; G.W. Stevenson. 2013. Values-based food supply chains: Full Circle. CIAS, University of Wisconsin.<br /> <br /> Scherr, Rachel, Rachel Cox, Gail Feenstra and Sheri Zidenberg-Cherr. 2013. Integrating local agriculture into nutrition programs can benefit childrens health. California Agriculture Vol 67(1): 30-37.<br /> <br /> Stevenson, G.W. 2013. Values-based food supply chains: Good Earth Farms. CIAS, University of Wisconsin. <br /> <br /> Stevenson, G.W. 2013. Values-based food supply chains: Home Grown Wisconsin Co-op. CIAS, University of Wisconsin. <br /> <br /> Stevenson, G.W. 2013. Values-based food supply chains: Idahos Bounty. CIAS, University of Wisconsin. <br /> <br /> Stevenson, G.W. 2013. Values-based food supply chains: Organic Valley. CIAS, University of Wisconsin. <br /> <br /> Stevenson, G.W. 2013. Values-based food supply chains: Red Tomato. CIAS, University of Wisconsin. <br /> <br /> Stevenson, G.W.; L. Lev. 2013. Values-based food supply chains: Country Natural Beef. CIAS, University of Wisconsin. <br /> <br /> Stevenson, G.W.; R. Pirog. 2013. Values-based food supply chains: Strategies for agri-food enterprises-of-the-middle. CIAS, University of Wisconsin.<br /> <br /> Yifat, Tal, Olivia Parry and Sarah Lloyd. "The Wisconsin Food Hub Cooperative: building infrastructure for a regional food system". In Alfonso Morales and Julie Dawson, Cities of Farmers: Problems, Possibilities and Processes of Producing Food in Cities. University of Iowa Press, forthcoming.<br /> <br /> Extension reports<br /> <br /> Arbuckle, J. Gordon Jr., Paul Lasley, and John Ferrell. 2012. Iowa Farm and Rural Life Poll: 2012 Summary Report. Extension Report PM3036. Ames, IA: Iowa State University Extension. (12 pp.)<br /> <br /> Campbell, D., C. Marshall, G. Feenstra, and R. Galt. 2012. Community food system bibliography, Davis, CA: UC Sustainable Agriculture Research and Education Program/Agricultural Sustainability Institute. [http://www.sarep.ucdavis.edu/sfs/CFSresources].<br /> <br /> Lasley, Paul, John Ferrell, and J. Gordon Arbuckle, Jr. 2013. The Role of Farm Families in Local Community Philanthropy. Extension Report PM3049. Ames, IA: Iowa State University Extension. (8 pp.)<br /> <br /> Values-based food supply chain case study: Co-op Partners Warehouse. 2013. CIAS Research Brief #87.<br /> <br /> Values-based food supply chain case study: Country Natural Beef. 2013. CIAS Research Brief #79.<br /> <br /> Values-based food supply chain case study: Full Circle. 2013. CIAS Research Brief #92.<br /> <br /> Values-based food supply chain case study: Good Earth Farms. 2013. CIAS Research Brief #88.<br /> <br /> Values-based food supply chain case study: Home Grown Wisconsin. 2013. CIAS Research Brief #69.<br /> <br /> Values-based food supply chain case study: Idahos Bounty. 2012. CIAS Research Brief #86.<br /> <br /> Values-based food supply chain case study: Organic Valley. 2013. CIAS Research Brief #80.<br /> <br /> Values-based food supply chain case study: Shepherds Grain. 2012. CIAS Research Brief #81.<br /> <br /> Values-based food supply chain case study: Red Tomato. 2013. CIAS Research Brief #82.<br /> <br /> Working paper<br /> <br /> Skilton, P., and Z. Wu. Governance Regimes for Protected Geographic Indicators: Impacts on Food Marketing Systems.<br />Impact Statements
- Advanced the theory and empirical study of value-based agricultural and food supply chains with particular focus on small and medium-sized farms and agribusiness enterprises.
Date of Annual Report: 03/19/2015
Report Information
Period the Report Covers: 10/01/2013 - 09/01/2014
Participants
Christy Anderson Brekken, Lily Brislen, Kate Clancy, David Conner, Lindsey Day Farnsworth, Gail Feenstra, Shermain Hardesty, Mary Hendrickson (Tuesday), Jan Joannides, Rob King, Bill Lacy, Larry Lev, Michelle Miller, Marcia Ostrom, Hikaru Peterson, Mary Ahearn (called in on Tuesday), Ge Backus (guest), Larry Burmeister (called in on Wednesday)Brief Summary of Minutes
General Project Discussion:The state project group members individually had another productive year. In addition to the activities listed here, many members were involved in issues on food and agriculture closely related to Ag of the Middle (AOTM). The two AFRI proposals generated from the 2012 meeting were resubmitted in 2014 and were recommended for funding. The proposals will contribute to the project objectives directly in coming years. The attendance was slightly lower than last year, but included a few new members.
The sub-committee on the Ag of the Middle website (http://agofthemiddle.org/) formed in the 2013 meeting presented the site redesigned by the UW-Madison Center for Integrated Agricultural Systems (CIAS) to reflect the group discussion in 2013. The AOTM website committee was officially formed, including the chair (Ostrom), reviewer for publications by non-members (Conner), and CIAS coordinator (Miller). Contextual contributions were assigned among website committee members and others. The group named groups of individuals that would form the target audience of the website and discussed the process to determine which publications would be included.
The group discussed various ways to promote AOTM to our professional audience. A small group decided to propose an organized symposium for the Food and Agricultural Marketing Policy Session track at the 2015 Agricultural and Applied Economics Association (AAEA) meetings. Yet another small group was formed to develop an AFRI conference grant proposal on supply chain governance, seeking to partner with other professional groups, such as the Inter-institutional Network for Food, Agriculture, and Sustainability (INFAS), Ag and Human Values, and peer-reviewed journals such as the Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development and Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics. The conference/workshop would be scheduled in Boston in 2016, where both Ag and Human Values and AAEA meetings are held in summer.
In addition, the group had an annual phone conference with the USDA AFRI Program Leader (Denis Ebodaghe), who administers the Small and Medium-Sized Farms priority area, and learned that no major change is expected in their Foundational Programs in terms of grant size and scope. Ebodaghe informed us about other upcoming grant opportunities, and the group informed him about the meaning of AOTM. The group learned from the guest attending the meeting about a producer-customer linking app that is developed and tested in the Dutch food system. The group was also briefed on a policy update.
The last topic of discussion was about a longer-term vision for the group’s work on AOTM. Since usable funds at UW-Madison CIAS are limited to support the AOTM site, the group members agreed to write in expenses to maintain it in future grant proposals. The group also agreed to apply for another five-year multi-state research project on AOTM when this project is completed.
Accomplishments
Accomplishments - October 2013 to September 2014:<br /> <br /> Outputs:<br /> <br /> Activities: <br /> <br /> Listed are the major grants involving NC-1198 project members. Members have written and submitted other grant proposals with other collaborators on issues related to AOTM that are not listed here. For example, Francis et al. have applied for a three-year grant from CERES Foundation called "Efficient Research Methods for Minimal-Cost Organic Agriculture" that will establish four demonstration/commercial gardens in each of two communities with Native American entrepreneurs in Northeast Nebraska. This is a cooperative project with Center for Rural Affairs.<br /> <br /> Grants Submitted and Awards Received by members<br /> <br /> Peterson, H.H., G.W. Feenstra, M.R. Ostrom, K. Tanaka, and C. Anderson-Brekken. “Impacts of Values-Based Supply Chains on Small and Medium-Sized Farms.” 2015-2017. USDA-AFRI, Small & Medium-Size Farms Priority area. Recommended for funding. [Obj 1, 2, 3, 4] <br /> <br /> Lev, L., R. King, J. Joannides, G. Feenstra, S. Hardesty. “Cultivating Specialty Food Industry Sales: New Opportunities for Small and Medium-Sized Farms.” USDA-AFRI, Small & Medium-Size Farms Priority area. Recommended for funding. [Obj 1, 2]<br /> <br /> Miller, M. “Regional food freight transportation study”. September 2014 – August 2015. USDA-AMS, Transportation Division [Obj 1, 4]<br /> <br /> Grant Proposals Submitted, not Funded<br /> <br /> De Master, K., S.K. Bowen, D. Conner, P. Howard, L. Lev, M. Miller, M. Ostrom, T. Yifat. “Factors Influencing the Resilience of Multifunctional Agri-Food Clusters in the U.S.” USDA-AFRI, Rural Communities and Regional Development Priority area. Not funded.<br /> <br /> Milestones:<br /> <br /> The major milestone was the two AFRI grants proposed by the NC-1198 project members being successfully recommended for funding starting in January 2015. Looking ahead, the launch of the renewed AOTM website and proposed organized symposium and AFRI conference proposal grant will be milestones.<br /> <br /> Impacts<br /> <br /> Activities:<br /> <br /> Many members are prolific in sharing the vision of Agriculture of the Middle and the latest research findings pertaining to the project objectives. In addition to the specific activities listed below, individual members have multiple ongoing activities related to AOTM.<br /> <br /> For example, the Sustainable Agriculture, Research & Education Program (SAREP) has been actively developing three types of research and outreach initiatives that relate to Ag of the Middle for the past several years: (1) farm to school/ farm to institution evaluation focusing on regional procurement, (2) assessing and developing markets for small and mid-scale, beginning and ethnic producers through values-based supply chains, and (3) exploring economic, health and community benefits of urban agriculture (Feenstra). All 3 areas involve “Ag of the Middle,” but from different perspectives. Having the opportunity to view the challenges of Ag of the Middle from consumer, retailer, wholesaler, distributor, processor and community perspectives, has allowed us to understand the issues in values-based supply chains from more of a systems lens. <br /> <br /> Many on-going activities are related to local foods. At Auburn University, for example, Worosz has been involved in community food security assessment, consumer study on purchasing local meats, and examination of local foods in colleges and universities. The local meat study emphasizes lower socio-economic status and minority groups which are not typically addressed in the literature. Some policy implications are expected from the last project. A recently-concluded grant at University of Nebraska Lincoln "Building Regional Food Systems," financed by USDA/AMS, surveyed farmers and consumers to assess their interest in growing more food for direct sale and for local markets (Francis). Another initiative on "Alternative Funding for Food System Development", funded by NCRC, involved workshops and focus groups looking for creative ways to finance local food systems. Also, a recently-completed North Central SARE grant on "Video Lessons in Sustainable Agriculture for High School Students" developed 20 short videos where high school students interview farmers on various sustainable farming practices, as well as local marketing and other aspects of alternative systems. <br /> <br /> Selected Presentations by members<br /> <br /> Feenstra, G. “Local and regional food systems: Opportunities for community engagement,” keynote speaker at the University of Arizona Food System Network Conference, Tucson, AZ, April 29, 2014 (200 attendees). [Obj 2]<br /> <br /> Feenstra, G. “Selling valuess-added produce in wholesale markets with your farm story,” moderator, speaker at the California Small Farm Conference, Rohnert Park, CA, March 12, 2014 (30 attendees). [Obj 1]<br /> <br /> Feenstra, G. “Procurement of local produce,” moderator, speaker at the Northern California Farm to School Conference, San Joaquin County, Stockton, CA, November 20, 2013 (10 attendees). [Obj 1]<br /> <br /> Feenstra, G. “Community-Based Regional Food Initiatives,” seminar presentation at University of Arkansas, Fayetteville, AR, November 13, 2013 (150 attendees). [Obj 2]<br /> <br /> Gray, T. 2014. “Need for Multi-stakeholder Cooperatives,” Presentation. Annual meetings of the Eastern Sociological Society. Baltimore, Maryland, February 22. <br /> <br /> Gray, T. 2014. “Democratization and Multi-stakeholder Cooperatives,” Presentation. Annual meetings of the Agriculture, Food, and Human Values Society. Burlington, Vermont. June 18-22.<br /> <br /> Hardesty, S. “Cottage Foods and Other Value-added Products.” Organizer/moderator/speaker at the California Small Farm Conference, Rohnert Park, CA, March 11, 2014 (30 attendees). [Obj 1]<br /> <br /> Miller, M. “Farming and Climate Change”, presented at a public forum, Wisconsin Academy of Sciences, Arts and Letters, Madison, WI, November 2013 [obj 3 &4]<br /> <br /> Miller, M. “The Economics and Culture of Local Food” presented at a public forum, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL, November 2013 [obj 1 &2]<br /> <br /> Miller, M. “Regional Food for Regional Markets”, Midwest value-added conference, Wausau, WI, January 2014 [obj 1 &2]<br /> <br /> Miller, M. “Moving Local Food to Wholesale Markets: Lessons from Practitioners”, Local Food Summit, Milwaukee, WI, January 2014 [obj 1 &2]<br /> <br /> Miller, M. “Regional Food to Regional Markets”, Center for Logistics, Trade, and Transportation, Gulfport, MS, February 2014 [obj 1]<br /> <br /> Miller, M. “(Re)creating Regional Food Systems”, American Planning Association – Wisconsin Chapter, Madison, WI, June 2014 [obj 1 & 2]<br /> <br /> Miller, M. Research conference “Innovations in Sustainable Agriculture and Food Supply Chains”, University of Exeter, September 2014 [obj 1]<br /> <br /> Telligman, A., M.R. Worosz, and C. Bratcher. 2014. Beliefs Underlying Purchases of Local Beef. Paper presented at Equity, Democracy, and the Commons: Counter-Narratives for Rural Transformation, the annual meetings of the Rural Sociological Society, New Orleans, LA, 30 Jul – 03 Aug. [Obj 2]<br /> <br /> ?<br /> Walker, D. and M.R. Worosz. 2014. The Role of Chefs and Restaurant Owners in Alabama’s Local Foods Movement. Paper presented at Equity, Democracy, and the Commons: Counter-Narratives for Rural Transformation, the annual meetings of the Rural Sociological Society, New Orleans, LA, 30 Jul – 03 Aug. [Obj 1]<br /> <br /> Yifat, T. “Sustainability and Farmer Control in an Agrifood Value Chain: The Case of Organic Valley.” Presented in the Annual General Meeting of the Canadian Association for Food Studies, St. Catharines, ON, May 24–27, 2014.<br /> <br /> Yifat, T. “Can Alternative Agrifood Value Chains Lead the Market? : The Case of Organic Valley.” Presented in the ASFS/AFHVS Annual Conference, Burlington, VT, June 18-22, 2014.<br /> <br /> Yifat, T. “Social and Environmental Upgrading in a Producer-Driven Agrifood Value Chain: The Case of Organic Valley.” Presented in the Society for the Advancement of Socioeconomics Annual Conference. Chicago, IL, July 10-12, 2014.<br /> <br /> Yifat, T. “Environmental Entrepreneurship and the Possibility of Green Capitalism.” Presented in the Society for the Advancement of Socioeconomics Annual Conference, Chicago, IL, July 10-12, 2014.<br /> <br /> Posters<br /> <br /> Walker, D., Y. Hu, M.R. Worosz, N. Wilson, J. Zanzot, C. Bailey, C. Zizza. 2014. Access to Nutritious Foods in Macon County Alabama. Poster presented at Collaboration and Innovation Across the Food System, the annual joint meetings of the Association for the Study of Food and Society (ASFS) and the Agriculture, Food and Human Values Society (AFHVS), Burlington, VT, Jun 18-22.<br /> <br /> Yeomans, D., M.R. Worosz, Y. Hu, J. Zanzot, N. Wilson, C. Bailey and C. Zizza. 2013. Macon County Community Food Security Assessment. Poster presented at Women and Youth: Changing the Landscape of Agriculture, the 71st Professional Agricultural Workers Conference, Tuskegee University, Tuskegee, AL, 08 – 10 Dec.<br /> <br /> Conferences/Workshops Organized by members<br /> <br /> “Cottage Foods: California’s Cottage Food Law, Food Safety, Production, Marketing and Managing a Cottage Foods Business”. Organized by S. Hardesty. 6 2-day workshops from May-July, 2014 in Northern California. [Obj 1]<br /> <br /> “Organizing On-Farm Farmers Markets and Farm Dinners”. Organized and moderated by S. Hardesty at the California Small Farm Conference, Rohnert Park, CA, March 11, 2014 (50 attendees). [Obj 1]<br /> <br /> ?<br /> Workshop organized by M. Miller at the Eco-apple growers annual meeting, Madison, WI, December 2013 [obj 3]<br /> <br /> Milestones:<br /> <br /> Looking ahead, the acceptance of the proposed track session on AOTM at the 2015 AAEA meetings and the development and successful funding of the AFRI conference grant proposal on supply chain governance will be milestones.<br /> <br /> Indicators:<br /> <br /> The list of project members has grown with a few new members attending the 2014 meeting. <br />Publications
Peer reviewed publications<br /> <br /> Anderson, C., L. Brushett, T. Gray, and H. Renting. 2014. “Group Editorial: Working Together to Build Cooperative Food Systems,” Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development. Vol. 4, No. 3. Spring.<br /> <br /> Becot, F., Conner, D., Kolodinsky, J. and Mendez, V. (2014). Measuring the costs of production and pricing on diversified farms: Juggling decisions amidst uncertainties. Journal of the American Society of Farm Managers and Rural Appraisers. 171-194.<br /> <br /> Becot, F., Conner, D., Nelson, A., Buckwalter, E. and Erickson, D. (2014). Institutional Demand for Locally-Grown Food in Vermont: Marketing Implications for Producers and Distributors. Journal of Food Distribution Research 45(2) 99-117.<br /> <br /> Conner, D., Sevoian, N. Heiss, S. and Berlin, L. (2014). The Diverse Values and Motivations of Vermont Farm to Institution Supply Chain Actors. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 27, 695-713.<br /> <br /> Feenstra, G. and D. Campbell. “Local and regional food systems.” In P.B. Thompson and D.M. Kaplan (Eds.), Encyclopedia of agricultural and food ethics [IN PRESS]. [Obj 2]<br /> <br /> Gray, T. 2014. “Commentary on Agricultural Cooperatives: “Tensions, Institutionalization, and the Need for Multi-stakeholder Cooperatives,” Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development. Vol. 4, No. 3. Spring.<br /> <br /> Hardesty, S., G. Feenstra, D. Visher, T. Lerman, D. Thilmany-McFadden, A. Bauman, T. Gillpatrick and G. Rainbolt. 2014. “Values-Based Supply Chains: Supporting Regional Food and Farms.” Economic Development Quarterly, 28:1,17-27. DOI:10.1177/0891242413507103. [Obj 1, 2]<br /> <br /> Heiss, S., Conner, D., Sevoian, N., & Berlin, L. (2014). Farm to Institution Programs: Organizing Practices that Enable and Constrain Vermont’s Alternative Food Supply Chains. Agriculture and Human Values. Published online July 23, 2014.<br /> <br /> King, R., M. Hand, G. DiGiacomo, K. Clancy, M. Gomez, S. Hardesty, L. Lev, E. McLaughlin and K. Park. In press. Growing Local: Case Studies in Local Food Supply Chains. University of Nebraska Press.<br /> <br /> LeBlanc, J., Conner, D., McRae, G. and Darby, H. (2014). Building Resilience in Nonprofit Food Hubs. Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development. 4(3) , 121-135.<br /> <br /> Miller, M. and J. Solin (in press). “The power of story for adaptive response – marshaling individual and collective initiative to create more resilient food systems” Journal of Environmental Studies and Sciences [obj 4]<br /> <br /> Surls, R., G. Feenstra, S. Golden, R. Galt, S. Hardesty, N.C. Napawan and C. Wilen. 2014. “Gearing up to support urban farming in California: Preliminary results of a needs assessment.” Renewable Agriculture and Food Systems, DOI:10.1017/S1742170514000052. Pp. 1-10. [Obj 2]<br /> <br /> Book chapters<br /> <br /> Thomas, W., N. Wilson, and M.R. Worosz. 2014. “Democratization of the Food System: Interests in a Food Policy Council in Alabama.” Pg. 18-25 in Auburn Speaks: Food, edited by P. Curtis and J. Lamar. Auburn University, Auburn, AL (ISBN: 978-0-615-97504-7).<br /> <br /> Extension reports<br /> <br /> Day-Farnsworth, L, Miller, M. (2014). Networking across the supply chain: Transportation Innovations in Local and Regional Supply Chains. [Obj 1& 4] http://www.trb.org/Policy/Blurbs/170956.aspx<br /> <br /> Miller, M., Hirsch, R., Werts, P and T. Green (2014). Extending your business range and reaching new clients with low-cost communications. Crops and Soils Magazine 2014 47:28-30. doi:10.2134/cs2014-47-1-9 [Obj 1& 3]<br /> <br /> Proceedings<br /> <br /> Miller, M. (2014) Resilient regional supply chains for sustainably-grown food. Proceedings of the Center for Logistics, Transportation and Trade Symposium, Gulfport, MS, USA, February 27, 2014 [Obj 1]<br /> <br /> ?<br /> Theses/dissertations<br /> <br /> Leamy, Ryan. (2014). Diversification Activities of Vermont Dairy Farmers: A Study of Raw Milk And Local Beef Processing In The State. Masters Thesis, Department of Community Development and Applied Economics, University of Vermont.<br />Impact Statements
Date of Annual Report: 02/22/2016
Report Information
Period the Report Covers: 09/30/2014 - 10/01/2015
Participants
Brief Summary of Minutes
Please see attached file for NC1198's 2014/2015 annual report.
Accomplishments
Publications
Impact Statements
Date of Annual Report: 01/15/2017
Report Information
Period the Report Covers: 10/01/2015 - 09/30/2016
Participants
J. Gordon Arbuckle, Jr., Iowa - Iowa State University (IOW), arbuckle@iastate.edu; Carmen Bain, Iowa - Iowa State University (IOW), cbain@iastate.edu; Christy A Brekken, OTHER-Oregon State University, Christy.Anderson.Brekken@oregonstate.edu; Lilian Brislen, OTHER-University of Kentucky, Lilian.Brislen@uky.edu; Larry L Burmeister, OTHER-Ohio University, burmeist@ohio.edu; Kate Clancy, OTHER-Independent Food Systems Consultant, klclancy@comcast.net; David S. Conner, Vermont - University of Vermont (VT), david.conner@uvm.edu; Kathryn De Master, California -Berkeley - University of California, Berkeley (CALB), kathryn.demaster@berkeley.edu; Michael D. Duffy, Iowa - Iowa State University (IOW), mduffy@iastate.edu; Rebecca D. Dunning, North Carolina – North Carolina State University, rddunnin@ncsu.edu; Lindsey Farnsworth, OTHER-University of Wisconsin-Madison, ldfarnsworth@wisc.edu; Gail W Feenstra, University of California-Davis (CALB), gwfeenstra@ucdavis.edu;Jill Fitzsimmons, Massachusetts - University of Massachusetts (MAS), Resource Economics, jillian24@gmail.com; Charles A Francis, Nebraska - University of Nebraska (NEB), cfrancis2@unl.edu; Thomas W. Gray, USDA, thomas.gray@wdc.usda.gov; Lauren E Gwin, OTHER-Oregon State University, lauren.gwin@oregonstate.edu; Shermain Hardesty, University of California-Davis, shermain@primal.ucdavis.edu; Keith Harris, Kansas – Kansas State University, Agricultural Economics, kdharris@ksu.edu; Mary Hendrickson, Missouri-University of Missouri, Rural Sociology, Hendricksonm@missouri.edu; Clare Hinrichs, Pennsylvania - Pennsylvania State (PEN), Agricultural Economics, Sociology, and Education, chinrichs@psu.edu; Philip Howard, Michigan – Michigan State University, Community Sustainability, howardp@msu.edu; Jan Joannides, OTHER-University of Minnesota, joann001@umn.edu; Robert King, Minnesota - University of Minnesota (MIN), Applied Economics, rking@umn.edu; Fred Kirschenmann, Iowa - Iowa State University (IOW), Leopold Center, leopold1@iastate.edu; Elizabeth Kramer, Georgia – University of Georgia, Agriculture and Applied Economics, lkramer@uga.edu; William Lacy, California -Davis - University of California, Davis (CALB), Human and Community Development, wblacy@ucdavis.edu; Daniel A. Lass, Massachusetts - University of Massachusetts (MAS), Resource Economics, dan.lass@resecon.umass.edu; Larry S. Lev, Oregon Cooperative Extension (ORE), Agricultural and Resource Economics, larry.lev@oregonstate.edu; Michelle Miller, Wisconsin-University of Wisconsin, mmmille6@wisc.edu; Marcia Ostrom, Washington - Washington State University (WN.P), WA Co-op Extension / Ctr for Sus. Ag & Nat. Res., mrostrom@wsu.edu; Hikaru Peterson, Minnesota- University of Minnesota (MIN), hhp@umn.edu; Stacey Sobell, Oregon – OTHER, Ecotrust, ssobell@ecotrust.org; Keiko Tanaka, Kentucky - University of Kentucky (KY), Community and Leadership Development, ktanaka@uky.edu; Michelle R Worosz, Alabama - Auburn University (ALA), Ag Econ & Rural Sociology, michelle_worosz@auburn.edu; Zhaohui Wu, OTHER-Oregon State University , wuz@bus.oregonstate.edu; Tal Yifat, OTHER-University of Chicago, tal@uchicago.edu
Brief Summary of Minutes
Brief summary of annual meeting:
Date: October 18-19, 2016
Location: Campus Club in Memorial Union, University of Minnesota; 300 Washington Ave. SE, Minneapolis, MN 55455
In attendance:
Lily Brislen, Larry Burmeister, Kate Clancy, David Conner, Libby Christensen, Jill Fitzsimmons, Gail Feenstra, Lauren Gwin, Shermain Hardesty, Keith Harris, Clare Hinrichs, Jan Joannides, Rob King, Liz Kramer, Larry Lev, Kelly Maynard, Michelle Miller, Marcia Ostrom, Hikaru Peterson, Keiko Tanaka, Michelle Worosz (Kathryn DeMaster called in on Oct. 19)
General Project Discussion:
Individually and in smaller groups, technical committee members have had another year of productive work on project objectives. New and ongoing funded grant projects have furthered project work and members have played prominent roles organizing and presenting professional conference sessions related to project themes. Additionally, many members have been involved in research, teaching and outreach related to food and agriculture topics that align with or inform inquiry related to Ag of the Middle (AOTM). Attendance at the 2016 annual meeting was somewhat lower than in 2015; however 5-6 committee members who did not attend specifically contacted the committee chair to convey their ongoing commitment to participate in the project, despite their absence at the 2016 annual meeting due to scheduling conflicts or funding shortfalls.
The 2014 and 2015 meetings included considerable attention to the public face of the project through its Ag of the Middle website (http://agofthemiddle.org/) redesigned and hosted by the UW-Madison Center for Integrated Agricultural Systems (CIAS). The 2016 meeting focused more on sharing and distilling recent work by committee members (more below and in the meeting minutes) in order to use this information and related ideas in organizing preparation and writing of a multi-state project renewal proposal, initiated Fall 2016 and to be submitted for NCRA review in early 2017. As NC-1198 concludes in September 2017, development of the renewal project was an urgent priority. Given the strongly shared sense that the present project objectives, with some adjustments, remain timely and relevant, the group focused its renewal project discussions on how to build from NC-1198 accomplishments thus far and also incorporate new and emerging research and programmatic needs. Throughout, the group continued to discuss strategies for communicating more widely and more effectively about AOTM research and its policy implications to our varied professional audiences and partner organizations.
As is the regular practice of this group at its annual meeting, there was a telephone conference with the USDA AFRI Program Leader (Denis Ebodaghe), who administers the Small and Medium-Sized Farms priority area. On Day 1 of the meeting, Ebodaghe informed us that the total number of proposal submissions his program received in 2016 had declined and they were expecting to fund 6-7 projects. He provided advice and insight about targeting grant projects that aim at knowledge addressing small/medium size farm issues in contrast to concerns of other enterprises in the supply chain or communities themselves. He also informed us of continuities and possible changes in this program at USDA and others relevant to AOTM concerns.
The annual meeting included considerable time working in small groups to take stock of accomplishments related to the present NC-1198 objectives and to discuss how those objectives should be revised, amended and/or supplemented for a renewal multi-state project. Discussions of the small groups were then reported back to the full group and submitted to further full group discussion. Assignments and timetable for preparing the renewal project proposal were negotiated and finalized. On Day 2 of the meeting, the group continued this work and also had a telephone conference with Administrative Adviser, Joe Colletti (Iowa State University), to review the renewal project objectives developed over the course of the meeting and our plans for submission of the renewal project proposal.