SAES-422 Multistate Research Activity Accomplishments Report
Sections
Status: Approved
Basic Information
- Project No. and Title: S1032 : Animal Production Systems: Synthesis of Methods to Determine Triple Bottom Line Sustainability from Findings of Reductionist Research
- Period Covered: 10/01/2016 to 09/30/2017
- Date of Report: 08/23/2017
- Annual Meeting Dates: 05/22/2017 to 05/24/2017
Participants
Alison Deviney N.C. State Univ. avdevine@ncsu.edu Brent Auvermann Texas A&M AgriLife Research b-auvermann@tamu.edu Brooke Latack Michigan State Univ. latack@msu.edu Chris Miller University of California Davis cmfmiller@ucdavis.edu Deanne Meyer UC Davis dmeyer@ucdavis.edu Erin L. Cortus South Dakota State Univ. erin.cortus@sdstate.edu Jactone A. Ogejo Virginia Tech arogo@vt.edu John J. Classen N.C. State Univ. john_classen@ncsu.edu Kevin Janni University of Minnesota kjanni@umn.edu Lide Chen University of Idaho lchen@uidaho.edu Luis F. Rodriguez University of Illinois lfr@illinois.edu Richard Koelsch Univ. of Nebraska -Lincoln rkoelsch1@unl.edu Robert E. DeOtte West Texas A&M Univ. rdeotte@wtamu.edu Ron Lacewell Texas A&M AgriLife Research r-lacewell@tamu.edu Shannon Banner N.C. State Univ. sbcreaso@ncsu.edu Wendy Powers University of California wendy.powers@ucop.edu Zifei Liu Kansas State Univ. zifeiliu@ksu.edu
Agenda:
- Review of 2017 annual meeting
- Timeline and writing team for the new project
- Election of officers
- Location and time for 2018 annual meeting
- Webinars
- Review of 2017 annual meeting
- A total of 22 people attended the meeting on Tuesday and 17 people attended the business meeting on Wednesday. Participants agreed that the meeting worked well for the planned activities as following.
- Monday (May 22):
- Tour of University of Nebraska research beef feedlot and introduction to beef systems and important characteristics of production – Galen Erickson (introductory information for Tuesday modeling exercise).
- Methane emissions field measurement for cattle – Thomas Winders
- ARS early warning system for earthen storage seepage – Bryan Woodbury
- Tuesday (May 23):
- Review the current project objectives and status- Brent Auvermann
- Disciplinary diversity
- Synthesize our research
- Interpretation of broader impacts of changes in animal systems
- Positioning the USMARC as a Model System for Antibiotic Resistance Transfer Research - Tommy Wheeler
- Pasture Systems and Watershed Management Research Unit: Approach to System Modeling of Nutrient Flow Through Agricultural Systems - Alan Rotz
- Assessing the long-term consequences of nitrogen and phosphorus losses from a grow-finish swine facility - Brooke Latack
- Break out groups to brainstorm assigned table question to show how we can link our individual research in animal protein production via the CLD. (Facilitators – Wendy, Bob, and Brent)
- Group 1: Does an increase in animal protein production cause an increase in manure spreading?
- Group 2: Are environmental regulations improving environmental Quality? What are the most powerful influences affecting the drive for environmental regulations?
- Group 3: Can we squeeze more out of an animal without increasing consumer cost?
- Group 4: What are the risk factors?
- Group: 5: Effects of market.
- Wednesday (May 24):
- Business meeting
- INFEWS-ER updates and discussion on how to participate - Luis F. Rodriguez
- New project rewrite discussions: How did participation in S1032 add value to your program? What are challenges in current proposal? What advances will we need?
- Define metrics for sustainability,
- Integrate INFEW-ER
- Tools development sharing
- Break out CLD into focused component
- Data dictionary
- Improved resource recovery
- Soil health jeopardize feed production
- Climate adaptation
- Heat stress adaptation
- New animal system design
- Reengaging with CLD quarterly
- Engaging with stakeholders
- Review the current project objectives and status- Brent Auvermann
- Timeline and writing team for the new project
- Ron Lacewell noted that the new S1032 project should be submitted by February, 2018; and Dr. Wendy Powers will be the new project advisor for the S1032 project. A new project writing team needs to be formed and the draft of the new project should be made available around November, 2017.
- The new project writing team: Deanne Meyer and Erin L. Cortus will be co-chairs of the writing team. John J. Classen, Luis F. Rodriguez, Richard Koelsch, Robert E. DeOtte, Jactone A. Ogejo, and Zifei Liu agreed to contribute to the writing.
- Election of officers
- Deanne Meyer nominated Kevin Janni for secretary. Robert E. DeOtte seconded. Kevin Janni agreed and was unanimously elected.
- Officials for 2016/2017: Chair – Erin Cortus; Vice chair – Zifei Liu; Secretary – Kevin Janni; Past chair – Jactone A. Ogejo.
- Location and time for 2018 annual meeting
- Location: Washington DC. It was expected NIFA official may show up, and a visit to ARS may be arranged during the 2018 annual meeting.
- Time: 2nd week in May or 2nd week of June, to be decided. Need to avoid the vacation season.
- Host for the 2018 annual meeting at DC: to be decided.
- Webinars
- Members agreed to have regular monthly webinars starting in September 2017. Zifei Liu agreed to continue to set up ZOOM meeting for monthly webinar as usual.
- Topics suggested
- September: NIFA contact to moderate a session
- October: Richard Koelsch.will lead a seminar regarding sustainability, food supply chain industry
- November: New faculty in NCSU and John Classen to lead a session
- December: CLD review, John Classen to lead
Meeting was adjourned at 8:25 am
Accomplishments
The accomplishments (collective and state based) for this reporting period are listed by the projects’ three objectives below. The participating states and respective principal investigators (PIs) are listed in Table 1.
Objective 1: Engage collaborators from needed broad range of disciplines, institutions, and stakeholder groups to catalyze conceptual and quantitative synthesis, collaboration, and data sharing.
Planned activities to accomplish this objective include: provide more learning and idea generation opportunities by increasing regular interactions among project participants using webinars and annual meeting format that allows structured analysis and discussions to achieve the goals of the group. Between June 2016 and May 2017, project participants completed the activities listed below towards this objective.
- The webinar series provided opportunities for learning, idea generation and collaborator identification. There were a total of eight webinars with 11 to 19 participants per webinar.
- August 09, 2016. Topics and schedule for 2016-2017 webinars were discussed through “AgriLife WebEx meeting”. Purpose and maintenance of S1032 website were discussed. There were thirteen participants.
- September 06, 2016. Project participants discussed potential funding sources/strategies for S1032 group to consider. Deanne Meyer introduced USDA Climate change RFA. Rick Koelsch reviewed AFRI Competitive Grants Program. John Classen introduced NSF research traineeship program. There were sixteen participants.
- October 04, 2016. Brent Auvermann presented progress in refining the CLD – focus on two examples to highlight latent variables concept and clarify units of measurement. Some variable structures for modeling poultry &livestock systems using object-oriented programming were proposed. There were twelve participants.
- November 08, 2016. Wendy Powers lead conversation of new S1032 project rewrite/renewal timeline and objectives. There were eleven participants.
- December 06, 2017. Luis F. Rodríguez presented the first quarterly review of “the INFEWS-ER” grant: a virtual resource center enabling graduate innovations at the nexus of food, energy, and water systems. There were nineteen participants.
- January 10, 2017. Deanne Meyer presented on data harmonization effort. There were eleven participants.
- March 07, 2017. Dr. Ben Turner from Texas A&M University-Kingsville presented on his recently published work “A systems approach to forecast agricultural land transformation and soil environmental risk from economic, policy, and cultural scenarios in the north central United States (2012–2062)”.
- April 11, 2017. Ezra Kahn and Peter Arbuckle from National Agricultural Library provided a presentation/updates on their digital commons work – a topic related to our efforts on data harmonization in general. The planning committee finalized the agenda for the S1032 annual meeting.
State |
Name |
CLD – Node/Loop |
Data/Resources |
Arkansas |
Jun Zhu |
B14, B19, B15 |
Data to develop a cost effective advanced anaerobic digester system that uses dry poultry litter as feedstock |
California |
Deanne Meyer |
R10, B11, B12, B13, B14, B15, B19, R18 |
Lagoons, feed, solid separation, biodigesters, flow (of solids, and nutrients) through commercial dairy operations |
Ruihong Zhang |
|
|
|
Wendy Powers |
B14, B15, B21, B26, R10, R25 |
Feed, production, excretion, pasture + soil GHG |
|
Idaho |
Lide Chen |
B13, B15, B19 |
Biodigesters, air quality |
Illinois |
Luis F. Rodriguez |
B4, B5, B11, B14, B15 |
|
Xinlei Wang |
|
|
|
Indiana |
T. Applegate |
|
|
Albert Heber |
|
|
|
Iowa |
Jacek A. Koziel |
B14, B15, R10, B11, B12 |
NAEMS data, AMPAT database on performance of odor, gas and dust emissions control technologies for livestock operations, Air Quality Laboratory, Olfactometry Laboratory. Lab-, pilot-, farm-scale set-ups for development and testing of emissions mitigation technologies. |
Kansas |
Zifei Liu |
B15, GHG |
Vegetative buffers and UV to reduce air pollutants from livestock facilities; Meta-analysis of NH4 and CH4 emissions from cattle operations; Estimating contributions of agricultural sources to air quality (PM2.5 and O3) through receptor modeling |
Kentucky |
Joseph Taraba |
|
|
Michigan |
Amor Ines |
|
|
Steven Safferman |
B13, B14, B15, B18, B19 |
Biodigesters, biomass feedstock |
|
Minnesota |
Kevin Janni |
R18, R19, B15 |
|
Larry Jacobson |
R18, B19, B15, GHG |
|
|
Mississippi |
John C. Schneider |
|
|
Missouri |
Teng Lim |
B17, B19, R10, R18 |
Manure management, air quality, and degradation of antimicrobials. |
Nebraska |
Amy M. Schmidt |
R10, B14, B16 |
Soil health; fate of nutrients, AMR bacteria, steroid hormones |
Rick Koelsch |
|
|
|
North Carolina |
Edward L. Kick |
R28, B21, B19 |
|
John J. Classen |
R28, B12, B13, B15, B26, B29, B30 |
Ammonia recovery, characteristics of scraped manure |
|
North Dakota |
Shafiqur Rahman |
R18, B15 |
Greenhouse gas, air quality |
Ohio |
Lingying Zhao |
|
|
South Dakota |
Erin L. Cortus |
R10, B11, B15, GHG |
NAEMS data, Confined beef cattle facility emission data, bedded manure packs; information transfer mechanisms |
Texas
|
Brent Auvermann |
All; B26, R10, B14, B15, B17, R18, B19 |
Land application of manure; dust, visibility, and bioaerosols; human health; antimicrobial resistance; Stella/Vensim models; beef LCA; biofuel feedstock characterization; compost characterization |
Kenneth D. Casey |
B14, B15, B17, GHG |
Emission data for NH3 and H2S from beef cattle feedlots, and H2S from open-lot dairy corrals. NAEMS data for OK4B Site. Emission data for N2O, CH4 and CO2 from the manure pack at beef cattle feedlots and open-lot dairy corrals. Water use data for feedyards and dairies. |
|
Robert E. DeOtte |
B14, Food Security |
Data on water conservation in meat packing plants, results of workshops on secure beef cattle production, biosecurity plans and continuity of operations plans for beef cattle production. |
|
Marty Rhoades |
|
|
|
Jovana Vukovic |
|
|
|
Brigette Guerrero |
|
|
|
Virginia |
Jactone A. Ogejo |
B13, B14, B15, B19 |
Lagoon, biodigesters |
Base causal loop diagram (CLD) to facilitate organization, synthesis, and integration of component-based research findings and supporting data is available from the administrative advisor
- The 2017 S1032 Annual Meeting was held in 219 LW Chase Hall, University of Nebraska’s East Campus, Nebraska, May 22-24, 2017. The meeting was hosted by Richard Koelsch. The meeting consisted of a tour of University of Nebraska research beef feedlot on Monday (May 22). A total of 22 people attended the meeting on Tuesday (May 23). Tuesday’s program include three presentations: (Positioning the USMARC as a Model System for Antibiotic Resistance Transfer Research - Tommy Wheeler; Pasture Systems and Watershed Management Research Unit: Approach to System Modeling of Nutrient Flow Through Agricultural Systems - Alan Rotz; Assessing the long-term consequences of nitrogen and phosphorus losses from a grow-finish swine facility - Brooke Latack); group discussions for reviewing the current project objectives and status; and breaking out groups to brainstorm assigned questions to show how we can link our individual research in animal protein production via the CLD. A total of 17 people attended the business meeting on Wednesday (May 24). Luis F. Rodriguez provided INFEWS-ER updates and discussion on how to participate. As part of the business meeting, the new project writing team was identified. Members agreed to continue monthly webinars starting from September 2017, and to have the 2018 meeting in Washington DC.
- Brent Auvermann and Rick Koelsch initiated weekly proposal-development web-conferences for the S1032 group in fall of 2016. AFRI priorities and proposal ideas were discussed. Weather variability and a changing climate creates critical vulnerabilities for animal feeding operations was identified as one topic. Examples of those vulnerabilities include: animal feed supply disruptions, increasing animal stress due to increasing temperatures and wet periods, greater risks to storage of manure, increasing disease/health risks for animals and human, extreme events disrupting and displacing AFOs and their managers, inability to recycle nutrients through land application systems.
- On behalf of S1032, Deanne Meyer from UC Davis worked with Carol Barford from the University of Wisconsin on a dairy data dictionary to move the group toward data harmonization. One webinar was devoted to an update of data harmonization progress and had participation from National Ag Library staff and U. Wisconsin on a monthly webinar. Deanne Meyer also participated in the NSF INFEWS PI meeting.
- Steven Safferman from Michigan State University is preparing a comprehensive literature review on winter manure application and soil health in conjunction with the North Central Water Network and Soil Health Institute. As part of the effort, an annotated bibliography of all related articles will be prepared and housed on the new Soil Health Institute Landscape Tool. Last literature review was published over 10 years ago.
- Teng Lim from University of Missouri is conducting a small project that assembles and analyzes soil health variable and land application of manure data, and compare the findings with a set of field plot data that are more controlled and replicated over the years. Key variables indicating soil health include water-stable aggregates, bulk density, and organic/active carbon.
- Erin Cortus engaged in a grant proposal that leveraged S1032 goals and collaborations, as well as connections with the INFEWS-ER Project (PI Rodriguez). This grant proposal engaged investigators outside of S1032 in the disciplines of natural resource management, agricultural economics and agricultural education. The proposal was titled “Curriculum Development for Wicked Problem Solving”, led by Dr. Benjamin Turner (Texas A&M University Kingsville). The proposal status is Under Review.
- Jacek Koziel made major progress to solve the livestock odor problem. A bio-based, soybean-derived, mitigates ammonia emissions up to 68%, major odorous volatiles up to 90%, without significant increase in nitrous oxide emissions. (2) “INFEWS/T4: The INFEWS-ER: a Virtual Resource Center Enabling Graduate Innovations at the Nexus of Food, Energy, and Water Systems” (Jan 2017 – Dec 2020) project was initiated (Koziel, co-PI). (3) Novel ‘aerobic-digestion & trench burial’ hybrid system was developed for biosecure and rapid disposal of infectious animal carcasses. Lab-scale research warrants field-scale studies.
- Shafiqur Rahman, North Dakota State University is working with nanoparticles in mitigating hydrogen sulfide and greenhouse gas emissions. In this study, Alginate-nZnO beads or bare nZnO proved to be an effective NP in reducing H2S (up to 99%), CH4 (49-72%); and CO2 (46-62%) from manure stored under anaerobic conditions and these reductions are likely due to the microbial inhibitory effect from nZnO, as well as chemical conversion. Both SEM-EDS and XPS analysis confirmed the presence of zinc sulfide (ZnS) in the beads, which is likely formed by reacting nZnO with H2
- Luis Rodriguez, Illinois, is the PI of the NSF INFEWS project entitled, “INFEWS/T4: The INFEWS-ER: a Virtual Resource Center Enabling Graduate Innovations at the Nexus of Food, Energy, and Water Systems”. The project has hosted a kick off meeting in April 2017. The members of S-1032 represent most INFEWS-ER steering committee membership. The project management team is in the process of recruiting participanting Faculy Fellows and Graduate Students to develop and enjoy learning modules. The INFEWS-ER is developing a website for hosting of learning modules targeting the development of graduate training in transdisciplinary food, energy, and water research. The inaugural symposia is tentatively schedules to occur in February of 2018.
Objective 2. Facilitate organization, synthesis, and integration of component-based research findings and supporting data.
The underlying premise of this objective is that project participants collaborate or work together in teams to build a component(s) of the relational aspects of animal protein production presented in the CLD. Participants will make/share data available to support the CLD work via a publicly accessible database. Planned activities to meet this objective include: (1) identifying the types of data participants have or being generated in their current work and (2) designing and hosting a publicly accessible database for sharing project data by participants to facilitate development/integration of system components outlined in the CLD (figure 1). The accomplishments towards achieving this objective include:
- Project participants continue to identify and update the nodes relevant to their work and also indicated sets of data they have available to share, as listed in table 1.
- Some examples of specific data available and/or current research activities by project participants to generate data for potential use in completing the CLD are listed below.
- Arkansas: Jun Zhu’s group continued their research on anaerobic digestion of poultry litter to produce renewable energy with focus on developing kinetic models to describe the digestion process. The Gompertz model was used and modified based on the experimental data and a new kinetic model was developed. The group still are working on the cleanup methods/technology in water recycling because this is still the major bottleneck for treating poultry litter using anaerobic digestion. Avoiding adding a large amount of water to litter to make it a liquid for the process has not made much progress. New methods such as non-thermal plasma technology, may need to be looked at to reduce the contaminants in the effluent water from the digester so that it can be recycled back to the digester. Other water cleaning technologies will also be investigated as well.
- California: Deanne Meyer and Carol Barford are currently interacting with French scientists who developed Animal Trait Ontology for Livestock. https://bioportal.bioontology.org/ontologies/ATOL. A separate dictionary is used by pork ISIC (http://unstats.un.org/unsd/cr/registry/regcst.asp?Cl=27).
- Iowa: Researchers led by Koziel continued to improve four mitigation technologies for odor and gaseous emissions from swine and poultry operations. Development and testing follows gated approach from lab- to pilot-, and finally to farm-scales. (1) Soybean-based treatment in a form of pit manure additive was tested on farm-scale. Non-sulfur VOC emissions were reduced by 36%. Ammonia emissions were reduced by 22%. Hydrogen sulfide emissions were reduced by 80%. No significant change to greenhouse gases emissions were observed. Estimated material cost of treatment is $1.45 per pig, equivalent of ∼8% of the pig market price. (2) Biochar was tested on a pilot-scale as a pit manure additive. Significant reductions in emissions were observed for ammonia (12.7–22.6%). Concomitantly, significant increases in methane emissions (22.1–24.5%) were measured. (3) Black light was tested on both laboratory and pilot-scale at a swine operation. Treatment reduced p-cresol emissions by 22%. Treatment reduced odor emissions by 16%. Treatment reduced nitrous oxide (a greenhouse gas) emissions by 9%. (4) Microbial-mineral treatment for surficial application to poultry manure was tested. Reduction levels of odorous volatile organic compounds was between 9% and 96% for microbial-mineral additive, depending on the analyzed compound.
- Idaho: Lide Chen’s team focused on mitigating gas emissions from manure application lands by using filtration/low sprinkler head irrigation and manure nutrient recycle by solid separation. They also conducted nutrient uptake research for which duckweed strains were cultivated on anaerobically digested dairy manure. Both lab and on-farm tests have been carried out. Preliminary data analysis has been conducted.
- Kansas: Zifei Liu’s group conducted a comprehensive review of life cycle assessment on carbon footprint of beef production in the US. The study will offer (1) an initial critical review on types of LCA methodology and allocation method used, the scope, scale and system boundary defined in the LCA applications in beef production; (2) an LCA comparison of different beef systems; (3) a ranging of results on carbon footprint of beef production based on conditions of the US beef production, trends in various indicators and the current data gap. Results of the LCA will be expressed in the unit of carbon footprint per kg product, and the main sources of uncertainty in the results will be identified. The results will provide a better understanding of the whole-farm greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from beef production, including emissions from feed production, from the enteric fermentation of the cattle, from the cattle's waste, and from processing and transportation, and the relative contributions of different system components.
- Michigan: Steven Safferman is maintaining online, publically available decision support tools to convert animal waste into a resource. Specifically, the Michigan Waste Biomass Inventory to Support Renewable Energy (Inventory) maps organic wastes in Michigan and conducts preliminary energy modeling. Included in the Inventory is manure from animal agriculture facilities. The Anaerobic Digestion Development Iterative Tool and the Combustion Renewable Energy Development Iterative Tool are companion tools to model the economic, renewable energy production, and greenhouse gas emissions reduction from blended feedstocks. Research is conducted on the development of a holistic phosphorus fate and transport index that includes consideration of manure application during different seasons. A major goal is to identify site-specific best management practices that maximize beneficial nutrient utilization while minimizing runoff. The research entails modeling the complex system using Hydrus and running various scenarios, typical of the Great Lakes states, to establish the index.
- Minnesota: A multidisciplinary team is conducting several research and demonstration projects with the overall goal to identify major energy uses for swine and dairy production and identify renewable energy options to replace fossil fuels (B19). The team measured energy use on two dairy and swine farms. They installed photovoltaic solar systems and monitored their energy production. Data collection and analysis is ongoing. New projects to install another photovoltaic system and provide sow cooling and piglet heating were funded.
- South Dakota: South Dakota has been working with colleagues at North Dakota State University and several centers of the USDA-ARS to collect and aggregate environmental and production data for confinement cattle operations in the Northern Great Plains. The data are being integrated into (through validation of or alterations to) the Integrated Farm System Model (v4, Rotz et al, 2016). This model incorporates multiple loops and nodes indicated in Figure 1 including, but not limited to B4, B5, B11 and R10. Initial simulations of cattle feeding systems (open lot, bedded pack) of varying capacities (750, 1500, 5000) in multiple locations in ND, SD and NE have been simulated for both current and projected climate conditions. The initial simulations provide a baseline for both system understanding and model evaluation.
- Virginia Tech worked on developing a compartmental based processed based model to improve the accuracy of estimating aerial emissions from stored dairy manure. The model estimates (i) spatial variation of temperature and substrate concentration (ii) spatial variations and rates of biogeochemical processes, and (iii) production and emission of ammonia from a liquid manure storage tank. Model performance was evaluated using experimental data obtained from National Air Emissions Monitoring Study. A sensitivity analysis was performed and air temperature, manure pH, wind speed, and manure total ammoniacal nitrogen concentration were identified as the most sensitive model inputs. Model simulations were run to estimate ammonia emission under different management and weather scenarios: two different manure storage periods in cold season from November to April and in warm season from May to October using historical weather data of the Rockingham County.
Objective 3. Discover (reveal), substantiate, and interpret the broader impacts of component-level modifications to animal production systems.
In Arkansas, the results from research provide new knowledge and useful information based on which further investigation of using liquid anaerobic digestion technology to treat a solid waste substrate such as poultry litter can be planned. The kinetic models developed can be applied to simulate the digestion process without having to conduct actual experiments, thus saving research costs while still obtaining important information on the performance of the digestion process so that better operating strategies can be explored and experimented. The ultimate product will be a better digestion technology that can be implemented at farm level for poultry producers to handle/abate the nutrients in poultry litter to reduce the environmental liability of their productions.
In California, annual report data quality submitted by dairy farmers was evaluated by determining if reported values were consistent with mass balance analyses of 1) excreted nutrients and, 2) land-applied N. This study compared the sum of excreted nutrients to that of applied and exported nutrients submitted in annual reports and used simulations to determine if reported N-application rates were reflective of existing agronomic limitations. Findings indicate opportunities for improvement likely exist in quantification of solid or liquid manure applied to land or plant material harvested from land. Additionally, opportunities for improvement in obtaining a representative sample likely exist. Progress is being made to define uncertainty introduced at farm level to determine amount of N, P, and K, removed from (as crops) fields where manure was applied. Each load of chopped forage from nine fields (3 each planted in corn, sorghum and cereal forages) was weighed and sampled for moisture and nutrient composition. This detailed dataset is useful to identify how different sampling protocols impact uncertainty of the answer. Work has begun to measure total and volatile solids as well as nutrient flows through commercial dairy operations (n=4 or 5). This is a one year field project. It will provide data to evaluate. Modification of previously developed eLearning decision support system occurred to aid dairy operators and consultants understand importance of collecting representative samples and quantification of material applied to land and removed as crops.
In Minnesota, a multidisciplinary team has developed educational materials and tools to convey critical concepts to enhance biosecurity for poultry and swine production facilities. A Biosecure Entry Education Trailer (BEET) was developed and videos produced to demonstrate key principles of Danish Entries. The BEET has been used with veterinary students, FFA members, company employees and producers. Presentations were made to producers groups in Minnesota and Missouri. In Minnesota, many sow barns use filter all air coming through inlets to reduce the airborne spread of porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome virus (PRRSV). Recent research reported leakage rates for sow barns. A model was developed to estimate indoor virus concentrations in a leaky sow barn with filtered inlets and a negative-pressure ventilation system.
In Iowa, Soybean-based treatment in a form of pit manure additive for mitigation of odor and gaseous emissions was developed and tested on a farm-scale. Significant reduction of main odorants was observed with no significant change to greenhouse gases emissions. Estimated material cost of treatment is $1.45 per pig, equivalent of ∼0.8% of the pig market price. Major advances were made to move black light treatment of odor and gaseous emissions from lab- to pilot-scale. Emissions of odor and one key greenhouse gas were reduced.
Impacts
- • Arkansas: Progressively refine a modeling framework, from the conceptual to the quantitative, that describes the relationships between (a) increasing demand for animal protein produced in the United States and (b) the social, economic, and environmental subsystems that sustain animal-protein production for the long term.
- • California: Provides a focus for utility and improvement of nitrogen management records as recommendations are developed for the Central Valley Regional Water Quality Control Board (policy) as they revise their dairy regulation. Improved eLearning system provides a platform for consultants and producers to discuss nutrient management and improve nitrogen management to be more protective of groundwater resources.
- • Michigan: High-level screening tool to model the blending of manure and other organic wastes to maximize renewable energy production using an anaerobic digester. Developing a soil phosphorus holding capacity index to help evaluate the site-specific effectiveness of best management practices
- • Iowa: Nearly 20 peer-reviewed papers published. Most papers involved multidisciplinary, multistate, multiagency collaborations. One third of published papers have international collaborators. Soybean-based treatment in a form of pit manure additive for mitigation of odor and gaseous emissions was developed and tested on a farm-scale. Significant reduction of main odorants was observed with no significant change to greenhouse gases emissions. Estimated material cost of treatment is $1.45 per pig, equivalent of ∼0.8% of the pig market price. Black light treatment of odor and gaseous emissions from livestock operations was successfully moved from lab- to pilot scale tests. Key odorous compound responsible for the characteristic downwind odor (p-cresol) was reduced by 22%. Treatment reduced odor emissions by 16% and nitrous oxide (a greenhouse gas) emissions by 9%, respectively. Major progress was made on early detection of bovine infectious diseases in collaboration with scientists from the National Animal Disease Center in Ames, IA and USDA- APHIS-WS-National Wildlife Research Center in Fort Collins, CO. Tuberculosis-infected cattle can now be identified by gases emitted from their feces. Novel ‘aerobic-digestion & trench burial’ hybrid system was developed for biosecure and rapid disposal of infectious animal carcasses. Lab-scale research warrants field-scale studies.
Publications
Journal Articles
Akdeniz,N., K.A. Janni, B.P. Hetchler. (2016) Mitigation of multiple air emissions from swine buildings using corn cob biofilters. Trans of ASABE 59(5): 1413-1420. (doi: 10.13031/trans.59.11873)
Baimatova, N, J.A. Koziel, B. Kenessov. 2017. Passive sampling and analysis of naphthalene in internal combustion engine exhaust with retracted solid phase microextraction device and GC-MS. Atmosphere, 8(7), 130. doi. 10.3390/atmos8070130.
Cai, L., S. Rice, J.A. Koziel, M. Dharmadhikari. 2017. Development of an automated method for selected aromas of red wines from cold-hardy grapes using solid-phase microextraction and gas chromatography - mass spectrometry – olfactometry. Separations, 2017, 4(3), 24. doi: 10.3390/separations4030024.
Cortus, E.L., B. Kasu, J. Jaquet, N. Embertson, A. Schmidt, T.T. Lim and J. Heemstra. 2017. Relevant information sources in the vast and complex manure nutrient management network. Submitted to Journal of Extension. Under Review.
Dobrzanski, Z., B. Buszewski, S. Opalinski, R. Kolacz, J.A. Koziel. 2017. Xenobiotics, toxic compounds, mutagens and carcinogens substances. Classification and regulatory challenges. Przemysl Chemiczny, 96(1), 76-84. doi:10.15199/62.2017.1.5.
Ellis, C., S. Rice, D. Maurer, R. Stahl, R. Waters, M. Palmer, P. Nol, J. Rhyan, K. VerCauteren, J.A. Koziel. 2017. Use of fecal volatile organic compound analysis to discriminate between non-vaccinated and BCG-vaccinated cattle prior to and after Mycobacterium bovis challenge. PLoS ONE, 2017, 12(7): e0179914. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0179914.
Kalus, K., S. Opalinski, D. Maurer, S. Rice, J.A. Koziel, M. Korczynski, Z. Dobrzanski, R. Kolacz, B. Gutarowska. Odour reducing microbial-mineral additive for poultry manure treatment. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 2017, 11(3), 7. doi: 10.1007/s11783-017-0928-4.
Kenessov, B., J.A. Koziel, N. Baikakina, D. Orazbayeva. 2016. Perspectives and challenges of on-site quantification of organic pollutants in soils using solid-phase microextraction. Trends in Analytical Chemistry, 85, 111-122.
Koziel, J.A. Successful grant-writing strategies for junior scientists: An American public university perspective. Higher School's Pulse, 2016, 10(4), 21-25. doi: 10.5604/20812021.1225356.
Koziel J.A., T.S. Frana, H.K. Ahn, T.D. Glanville, L.T. Nguyen, H. van Leeuwen. 2017. Efficacy of NH3 as a secondary barrier treatment for inactivation of Salmonella Typhimurium and methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus in digestate of animal carcasses: Proof-of-concept. PLoS ONE, 2017, 12(5): e0176825. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0176825.
Koziel, J.A., Nguyen, L.T., T.D. Glanville, H.K. Ahn, T.S. Frana, J.H. van Leeuwen. 2017. Method for sampling and analysis of volatile biomarkers in process gas from aerobic digestion of poultry carcass using time-weighted average SPME and GC-MS. Food Chemistry, 232, 799-807. doi: 10.1016/j.foodchem.2017.04.062.
Liu, Y., Liu, Z., Murphy, J., & Maghirang, R. 2017. Source apportionment of ambient PM2.5 by using UNMIX and PMF at rural and urban site in Kansas. J. Environ. Sci. Under review.
Liu, Z, Y. Liu, J. Murphy, and R. Maghirang. 2017. Contributions of Kansas rangeland burning to ambient O3: analysis of data from 2001 to 2016. Sci. Total Environ. Special issue: Health impact of wildland fire smoke exposure. Under review.
Liu, Z, Y. Liu, J. Murphy, and R. Maghirang. 2017. Ammonia and methane emission factors from cattle operations expressed as losses of dietary nutrients or energy. Agriculture. 7(3),16; doi:10.3390/agriculture7030016.
Liu, Z, Y. Liu, J. Murphy, and R. Maghirang. 2017. Estimating ambient ozone effect of Kansas rangeland burning with receptor modeling and regression analysis. Environments. (4)14; doi:10.3390.
Liu, Z, Y. Liu, X. Shi, J. Murphy, and R. Maghirang. 2017. Enteric methane conversion factor for dairy and beef cattle: Effects of feed digestibility and intake level. Trans. ASABE. (60)2 459-464.
Liu, Z, Y. Liu, X. Shi. J. Murphy, and R. Maghirang. 2017. Variations of ammonia emissions from cattle operations: Effects of temperature and dietary crude protein content. Trans. ASABE. (60)1: 215-227.
Liu, Z., Murphy, J., Maghirang, R. and Devlin, D. 2016. Health and environmental impacts of smoke from vegetation fires: a review. J. Environ. Prot. 7, 1860-1885. doi: 10.4236/jep.2016.712148.
Liu, Z, Y. Liu, R. Maghirang, D. Delvin, C. Blocksome. 2016. Estimate contributions of prescribed rangeland burning in Kansas to ambient PM2.5 through source apportionment with the Unmix receptor model. Trans. ASABE. 59(5).
Maurer, D., J.A. Koziel, K. Bruning, D.B. Parker. 2017. Farm-scale testing of soybean peroxidase and calcium peroxide for surficial swine manure treatment and mitigation of odorous VOCs, ammonia, hydrogen sulfide emissions. Atmospheric Environment, 166, 467-478. doi: 10.1016/j.atmosenv.2017.07.048.
Maurer, D., J.A. Koziel, K. Kalus, D. Andersen, S. Opalinski. 2017. Pilot-scale testing of non-activated biochar for swine manure treatment and mitigation of ammonia, hydrogen sulphide, odorous VOCs, and greenhouse gas emissions. Sustainability, 9(6), 929, doi: 10.3390/su9060929.
Maurer, D., J.A. Koziel, K. Bruning. 2017. Field scale measurement of greenhouse gas emissions from land applied swine manure. Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering, 2017, 11(3), 1, doi: 10.1007/s11783-017-0915-9.
Maurer, D., J.A. Koziel, K. Bruning, D.B. Parker. 2017. Pilot-scale testing of renewable biocatalyst for swine manure treatment and mitigation of odorous VOCs, ammonia, and hydrogen sulfide gas emissions. Atmospheric Environment, 150, 313-321. doi: 10.1016/j.atmosenv.2016.11.021.
Miller, C.M.. P.L. Price and D. Meyer. 2017. Mass balance analyses of nutrients on California dairies to evaluate data quality for regulatory review. Science of the Total Environment 579 (2017) 37–46. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2016.10.092
Onuki, S., J.A. Koziel, W.S. Jenks, L. Cai, D. Grewell, J.H. van Leeuwen. 2016. Taking ethanol quality beyond fuel grade: a review. Journal of the Institute of Brewing, 122(4), 588-598. doi: 10.1002/jib.364.
Orazbayeva, D., B. Kenessov, J.A. Koziel, D. Nassyrova, N.V. Lyabukhova. 2017. Quantification of BTEX in soil by headspace SPME-GC-MS using combined standard addition and internal standard calibration. Chromatographia, 80(8), 1249-1256. doi: 10.1007/s10337-017-3340-0.
Parker, D.B., M.B. Rhoades, B.H. Baek, J.A. Koziel, H.M. Waldrip, R.W. Todd. 2016. Urease inhibitor for reducing ammonia emissions from an open-lot beef cattle feedyard in the Texas High Plains. Applied Engineering in Agriculture, 32(6), 823-832. doi: 10.13031/aea.32.11897.
Shen, J. and J. Zhu. 2016. Kinetics of batch anaerobic co-digestion of poultry litter and wheat straw including a novel strategy of estimation of endogenous decay and yield coefficients using numerical integration. Bioprocess and Biosystems Engineering 39(10): 1553-1565.
Soso, S.B., J.A. Koziel. 2017. Characterizing the scent and chemical composition of Panthera leo marking fluid using solid-phase microextraction and multidimensional gas chromatography-mass spectrometry-olfactometry. Scientific Reports, 7(1):5137. doi: 10.1038/s41598-017-04973-2.
Wu, S., J. Zhu, and L. Chen. 2017. Feeding schemes and C/N ratio of a laboratory-scale set-fed sequencing batch reactor for liquid swine manure treatment. Journal of Environmental Science and Health, Part A (http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/10934529.2017.1301748)
Zhu, W., J.A. Koziel, D.L. Maurer. 2017. Mitigation of livestock odors using a black light and a new titanium dioxide-based catalyst: proof-of-concept. Atmosphere, 8(6), 103. doi: 10.3390/atmos8060103.
Conference Proceedings
Brown, J.T., T.-T. Lim, J.M. Zulovich, C. Costello, 2017. Evaluation of mechanical scraper system finishing barn for solid-liquid separation. In: Annual International Meeting, ASABE Paper No. 1701558. St. Joseph, Mich.: ASABE. Spokane, Washington, July 16-19. Spokane, Washington.
Chen, L., K. Kruger. 2017. Cultivation of duckweed on anaerobically digested dairy manure for nitrogen and phosphorus removal. Proceedings of Waste to Worth 2017. Cary, North Carolina, April 17-21, 2017. (https://articles.extension.org/pages/74382/cultivation-of-duckweed-on-anaerobically-digested-dairy-manure-for-nitrogen-and-phosphorus-removal)
De Haro-Marti, M.E., M. Chahine, H. Neibling, and L. Chen. 2017. Composting of dairy manure with the addition of zeolites to reduce ammonia emissions. Proceedings of Waste to Worth 2017. Cary, North Carolina, April 17-21, 2017. (https://articles.extension.org/pages/74395/composting-of-dairy-manure-with-the-addition-of-zeolites-to-reduce-ammonia-emissions)
Dong, Y., Safferman, S. I., Tekesin, O., Sengupta, S., Schorr, J. R., and Revur, R. (2016). “Removal of Nutrients from Agricultural Drainage Water using Nano-Engineered Porous Ceramic Media.” 2016 Annual International ASABE Meeting, Orlando, Florida.
Janni, K.A., L.D. Jacobson, S.L. Noll, C.J. Cardona, H.W. Martin A.E. Neu (2016) Engineering challenges and responses to the highly pathogenic avian influenza outbreak in Minnesota in 2015. ASABE Paper No. 162537392. ASABE, St. Joseph, MI, 49085.
Janni, K.A., M. M. Torremorell, L.D. Jacobson, C. Alonso, B.P. Hetchler. (2017) Modeling airborne virus concentrations in filtered swine barns with negative-pressure ventilating systems. ASABE Paper No. 170058. St. Joseph, MI: ASABE.
Karunarathne, S.A., M. Chung, J.A. Ogejo. Compartmental process-based model for estimating ammonia emission from liquid dairy manure storage tank ASABE paper No. 1701433. Spokane, WA, 2017.
Kenessov, B., J.A. Koziel. 2017. Modelling of time-weighted average air sampling by retracted SPME fibers using COMSOL Multiphysics software. In the proceedings of the ExTech 2017 19th International Symposium of Advances in Extraction Technologies, Santiago de Compostela, June 2017.
Lim, T.-T., J.T. Brown, J.M. Zulovich, C. Christine, 2017. Evaluation of a solid-liquid manure separation barn. In: Waste to Worth Conference. Cary, NC, April 18-21, 2017. Cary, NC.
Liu, Y. and Z. Liu. Apportionment of visibility degradation to sources of PM2.5 in rural and urban Kansas. ASABE paper No. 1700420. Spokane, Washington. 2017.
Liu, Z., Y. Liu, Ronaldo Maghirang. Contribution of Kansas pasture burning to ambient ozone. The 2nd International Smoke Symposium (ISS2), Long Beach, November, 2016.
Liu, Z., Y. Liu. Contribution of Kansas pasture burning to ambient ozone: a combination of receptor modeling, time series and regression analysis. ASABE paper No. 162460949. Orlando, Florida, 2016.
Liu, Y., Z. Liu. Source apportionment of ambient PM2.5 by using Unmix and PMF reception models at Flint Hills rural site and Kansas City urban site. ASABE paper No. 162447784. Orlando, Florida, 2016
Liu, Z, Y. Liu, R. Maghirang, D. Delvin, C. Blocksome. Estimate contributions of prescribed pasture burning in Kansas to ambient PM2.5 through source apportionment using Unmix receptor model. ASABE paper No. 162459373. Orlando, Florida, 2016.
Maurer, D.L., J.A. Koziel, K. Bruning, D.B. Parker. 2017. Pilot-scale concept of real-time wind speed-matching wind tunnel for measurements of gaseous emissions. ASABE Paper #1701656. 2017 ASABE Annual International Meeting, Spokane, Washington, July, 2017. doi: 10.13031/aim.201701656.
Maurer, D.L., J.A. Koziel, K. Bruning, D.B. Parker. 2017. Renewable biocatalyst for swine manure treatment and mitigation of odorous VOCs, ammonia and hydrogen sulfide emissions: Review. ASABE Paper #1701655. 2017 ASABE Annual International Meeting, Spokane, Washington, July, 2017. doi: 10.13031/aim.201701655.
Rice, S., Tursumbayeva, M., Dharmadhikari, M., Fennel, A., Koziel, J.A. 2017. Effects of harvest time on aroma of wines made from Brianna and Frontenac Gris grapes using gas-chromatography-mass-spectrometry and olfactometry. Presentation at the 42nd Annual Conference and Symposium of the American Society for Enology and Viticulture - Eastern Section; Charlottesville, VA, July, 2017.
Shen, J., J. Zhu. 2016. Kinetics of biogas production in batch anaerobic co-digestion of poultry litter and wheat straw mixed with municipal wastewater. ASABE Annual International Meeting paper#: 162458093, Orlando, FL. July 17-20, 2016.
Shen, J., J. Zhu. 2016. Biogas production in a biofilm reactor of a two-phase anaerobic digestion system from hydrolysate derived from poultry litter at different organic loadings and retention times. ASABE Annual International Meeting paper#: 162460548, Orlando, FL. July 17-20, 2016.
Shen, J., J. Zhu. 2016. Development of a novel strategy for estimation of endogenous decay and yield coefficients in batch biogas production of anaerobic co-digestion of poultry litter and wheat straw using numerical integration. ASABE Annual International Meeting paper#: 162457488, Orlando, FL. July 17-20, 2016.
Smith, J. S., Safferman, S. I., Costantini, L., and Ikeda, N. (2016). “Laboratory Investigation of Nutrient Fate during Winter Manure Application.” International ASABE Meeting, Orlando, Florida.
Swaminathan, P., A. Fennell, K. Besler, Y. Yao, S. Rice, J. Koziel, M. Dharmadhikari, D. Maurer, E. Del Bel, Z. Vickers, K. Cook, A. Hegeman, J. Luby. Characterization of grape berry ripening - genomics to sensory. Ninth RECOMB/ISCB Conference on Regulatory & Systems Genomics, with DREAM Challenges & Cytoscape Workshop, Phoenix, AZ, November 2016.
Tursumbayeva, M., J.A. Koziel, D.L. Maurer. 2017. Novel method for quantification of odorous volatiles in the air with solid-phase microextraction and gas chromatography - mass spectrometry. Presentation at the 129th Annual Meeting of the Iowa Academy of Science & 84th Iowa Junior Academy of Science Symposium, Cedar Falls, IA, April 2017.
Wallace, J. and Safferman, S. (2015). “Discharge Quality Water from Dairy Manure: a Summary of the McLanahan Nutrient Separation System.” Waste 2 Worth 2015 Advancing Sustainability in Animal Agriculture, Seattle, Washington.
Wang, H., T.-T. Lim, W. Wang, 2017. Feasibility of co-digesting swine manure with corn stover. In: Annual International Meeting, ASABE Paper No. 1701558. St. Joseph, Mich.: ASABE. Spokane, Washington, July 16-19. Spokane, Washington.
Thesis/Dissertations
Madina Tursumbayeva. Simple and accurate quantification of odorous volatile organic compounds in air with solid phase microextraction and gas chromatography - mass spectrometry. M.S. thesis. Iowa State University, July 2017. Major professor = Jacek Koziel.
Extension and Outreach
Janni, K.A. 2016. Identifying Biosecurity Hazards by Considering Flows on Animal Farms. p.2. UM Extension. Online at http://www.extension.umn.edu/agriculture/poultry/biosecurity/beet/index.html
Janni, K.A. 2016 Biosecure entry education trailer (BEET). p.2. UM Extension. Online at http://www.extension.umn.edu/agriculture/poultry/biosecurity/beet/index.html
Liu, Z. 2017. A guide to composting animal manure. Kansas State University Agricultural Experiment Station and Cooperative Extension Service. Under review.
Liu, Z. 2017. Design and management of biofilters for air pollution control in livestock facilities. Kansas State University Agricultural Experiment Station and Cooperative Extension Service. MF3387.
Liu, Z. 2017. Diet and feed management to reduce gaseous emissions from livestock production: principles and practices. Kansas State University Agricultural Experiment Station and Cooperative Extension Service. MF3386.
Liu, Z. 2017. National Air Quality Site Assessment Tool (NAQSAT) for livestock producers. Kansas State University Agricultural Experiment Station and Cooperative Extension Service. MF3367.
Liu, Z. 2017. How much does Kansas rangeland burning contribute to ambient PM2.5? Kansas State University Agricultural Experiment Station and Cooperative Extension Service. MF3358.
Liu, Z. 2017. How much does Kansas rangeland burning contribute to ambient ozone? Kansas State University Agricultural Experiment Station and Cooperative Extension Service. MF3357.
Other
Chen, L. 2016. Understand the 5 most influencing factors in composting manure. Progressive Dairyman November, 2016 (http://www.progressivedairy.com/topics/manure/understand-the-5-most-influencing-factors-in-composting-manure).
Chen, L. 2016. Achieve maturity at the end of the manure composting process. Progressive Dairyman September, 2016 (http://www.progressivedairy.com/topics/manure/achieve-maturity-at-the-end-of-the-manure-composting-process).
Janni, K.A. Enhancing Biosecurity Using Flow Analysis and Danish Entry Concepts. March 16, 2016. Midwest Poultry Convention. St. Paul, MN
Janni, K.A. Biosecure Entry Adaptations. June 16, 2016. Minnesota Turkey Growers Association Summer Conference, Duluth, MN
Janni, K.A. Prevention – Biosecurity Training, Plans and Execution. March 13 & 14, 2017. University of Missouri Extension Preventing and Responding to Disease Outbreak Workshops. Neosho and Buffalo, Missouri.
Lim, T.-T. 2017. Static Pile Aeration. Bi-State Compost School by University of Illinois and University of Missouri. Belleville, IL. June 21-22, 2017.
Lim, T.-T., C. Wang, A.J. Heber, N. Ji-Qin, L. Zhao, 2017. Effect of Electrostatic Precipiration on Particulate Matter Emissions from a high-rise layer house. In: Air Quality and Livestock Production. Australia: CRC Press. Eds., Banhazi, T., A. Aland, J. Hartung. (in press).
Meyer, D. 2017. California Plant and Soil Conference. Poster presentation. January 31 – February 1, 2017 DoubleTree Hotel, 2233 Ventura Street, Fresno, CA 93721