SAES-422 Multistate Research Activity Accomplishments Report
Sections
Status: Approved
Basic Information
- Project No. and Title: NC_OLD1178 : Impacts of Crop Residue Removal for Biofuel on Soils (formerly NC1017)
- Period Covered: 10/01/2012 to 09/01/2013
- Date of Report: 08/14/2013
- Annual Meeting Dates: 06/02/2013 to 06/05/2013
Participants
Mahdi Al-Kaisi, Iowa State University; Francisco Arriaga, University of Wisconsin; Humberto Blanco, University of Nebraska; Larry Cihacek, North Dakota State University; Mohammad Golabi, University of Guam; Sandeep Kumar, South Dakota State University; Rattal Lal, The Ohio State University; Birl Lowery, University of Wisconsin, (ex-officio); Randy Miles, University of Missouri; Kenneth Olson, University of Illinois; DeAnn Presley, Kansas State University; Diane Stott, USDA-ARS;
[Minutes]
Accomplishments
Over a 5-year period, no-till showed the highest SOC levels while conventional tillage had the lowest SOC on severely eroded soils in Guam. Soil OC was generally higher at depths below 10 cm for all tillage Treatments. Inclusion of sunnhemp (Crotalaria juncea L.) as a cover crop on conventionally tilled soils increased SOC in the upper 10 cm of the soil but not as high as no-till. Regardless of tillage/residue treatment, all soils have SOC contents of <1.5% under cropped/cultivated conditions. (GU)
After 3 years of corn residue removal, no significant reduction in grain yield was observed due to the residue removal. However, only with adoption of no-till and N rates > 150 lbs N/A with little residue removal were potential SOC increases observed. On a poorly drained site, 2.5-3.5 T/A residue needs to be retained to maintain SOC, while, 3.0-3.5 T/A is needed on a well drained site. Removal of 100% of the residue regardless of tillage or increased N fertilization resulted in higher soil bulk density and reduced soil aggregation. (IA)
Studies on long-term (25 year) tillage plots showed that cover crops did not affect corn or soybean plant populations over a 6 year period. Effects of combining cover crops with residue removal over 3 cropping years on corn and soybean yields were mixed and appear to be more related to tillage practice. (IL)
Severe drought affected residue removal studies in that significant plant death occurred at both sites studied. Yields were > 75 % lower than normal, resulting in very low residue levels at both sites affecting the ability to remove residue in a meaningful manner. (KS)
Collection of crop residue from seven long-term (>10 years) diverse no-till cropping systems shows a potential need for increased N fertilizer applications to compensate for heavy residue accumulation in some systems. (ND)
No difference in crop yields among different residue removal treatments on two 4-year trials on irrigated corn were observed. Greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions were lower where corn stover was removed than where it was not removed. A winter rye cover crop to mitigate C losses due to stover removal did not affect CO2 emissions. Residue removal effects on soil erodibility may be greater than that on corn yields and soil C pools in the short term under irrigated conditions. (NE)
Residue retention had significant impact on water runoff and sediment transport in simulated rainfall studies. Residue management treatments had clear effects on corn grain and stover yield in 2012 on both 8 year old and 1 year old study sites. Complete residue removal reduced grain yields 40-45% while 50% removal reduced grain yields 12-23%. (OH)
Impacts
- Crop residue removal affects maintenance of SOC and soil aggregate stability at specific locations.
- Under certain conditions, crop residue removal can influence soil bulk density.
- Removal of crop residues may negate the beneficial effects of no-till on soils
- Management of crops, cover crops, crop residues, and tillage influences SOC distribution in the soil profile
Publications
Al-Kaisi, M. and J. Guzman. 2013. Effects of tillage and nitrogen rate on decomposition of transgenic Bt and near-isogenic non-Bt maize residue. Soil and Tillage Research Journal. 129: 32-39.
Al-Kaisi, M., R. Elmore, J. Guzman, H. Hanna, C. Hart, M. Helmers, E. Hodgson, A. Lenssen, A. Mallarino, A. Robertson, and J. Sawyer. 2013. Drought impact on crop production and soil environment: 2012 experiences from Iowa. JSWC. 68 (1): 19-24.
Al-Kaisi, M., and J. Guzman. 2011. Residue biomass removal and potential impact on production and environmental quality. p.131-138. In Proc. 23th Annual Integrated Crop
Management Conference, Iowa State University, Ames, IA. Nov. 30 to Dec.1.
Blanco-Canqui, H. 2013. Crop residue removal for bioenergy reduces soil carbon pools: How can we offset carbon losses? Bioenerg. Res. 6:358-371.
Blanco-Canqui, H., Benjamin, J.G. 2013. Impacts of soil organic carbon on soil physical behavior. 2012. Advances in Agricultural Systems Modeling. Soil Science Society of America, Inc. 3:11-40.
Bonin, C. and R. Lal. 2012. Bioethanol potentials and life-cycle assessments of biofuel feedstocks. Crit. Rev. Plant Sci. 31:271-289.
Bonin, C. and R. Lal. 2012. Agronomic and ecological implications of biofuels. Adv. Agron. 117:1-50.
Johnson, J.M.F., W.W. Wilhelm, D.L. Karlen, D.W. Archer, B.J. Wienhold, D.T. Lightle, D.A. Laird, J.M. Baker, T.E. Ochsner, J.M. Novak, A.D. Halvorson, F.J. Arriaga, and N.W. Barbour. 2010. Nutrient removal as a function of corn stover cutting height and cob harvest. BioEnergy Res. 3:342-352.
Karlen, D.L. Varvel, G.E., Johnson, J.M-F., Baker, J.M., Osborne, S.L., Novak, J.M., Adler, P.R., Roth, G.W. and Birrell, S.J. Monitoring soil quality to assess the sustainability of harvesting corn stover. Agron. J. 103:288-295. 2011.
Lal, R., J.A. Delgado, J. Gulliford, D. Nielsen, C.W. Rice and R.S. Van Pelt. 2012. Adapting agriculture to drought and extreme events. J. Soil and Water Conserv. 67(6): 162A-166A.
Olson, K.R., A. N. Gennadiyev, A. P. Zhidkin, M. V. Markelov, V.N. Golosov and J. M. Lang. 2013. Magnetic tracer methods to determine cropland erosion rates. Catena. 104:103-110.
Olson, K.R. 2013. Soil organic carbon sequestration in U.S. cropland: Protocol development. Geoderma 195-196: 201-206.
Olson, K.R., S.A. Ebelhar and J.M. Lang. 2013. Effects of 24 years of tillage on SOC and crop productivity. Special edition. Soil Management for Sustainable Agriculture 2013. Applied and Environmental Soil Science 2013 (1):1-10.
Olson, K.R. A. N. Gennadiyev, R. G. Kovach and J. M. Lang. 2013. The use of fly ash to determine the extent of sediment transport on nearly level western Illinois landscapes. Soil Science 178(1):24-28.
Shaver, T., R. Ferguson, G. Hergert, Shapiro, C. Wortmann, and S. van Donk. 2013. Stover harvest through grazing and baling and the effects on soil properties. Crop Production Clinics 2103 Proceedings. University of Nebraska-Lincoln. Extension.
van Donk, S.J., D.L. Martin, S. Irmak, S.R. Melvin, J.L. Petersen, and D.R. Davison. 2010. Crop residue cover effects on evaporation, soil water content, and yield of deficit-irrigated corn in west-central Nebraska. Transactions of the ASABE 53:1787-1797.
van Donk, S.J., T.M. Shaver, J.L. Petersen, and D.R. Davison. 2012. Effects of crop residue removal on soil water content and yield of deficit-irrigated soybean. Transactions of the ASABE 55:149-157.
Vogel, K.P., Follett, R.F., Varvel, G.E., Mitchell, R.B., and Kimble, J.M. Soil carbon sequestration by maize and switchgrass grown for bioenergy. BioEnergy Research. 5(4): 866-875. 2012, DOI: 10.1007/s12155-012-9198-y.
Wienhold, B.J. and J.E. Gilley. 2010. Cob removal effect on sediment and runoff nutrient loss from a silt loam soil. Agron. J. 102:1448-1452.
Wienhold, B.J., G.E. Varvel, and V.L. Jin. 2011. Corn cob residue carbon and nutrient dynamics during decomposition. Agron. J. 103:1192-1197.
Wilhelm, Wally W., Hess, J. Richard, Karlen, Douglas L., Johnson, Jane M.F., Muth, David J.,Baker, John M., Gollany, Hero T., Novak, Jeff M., Stott, Diane E., and Varvel, Gary E. Review: Balancing limiting factors & economic drivers for sustainable Midwestern U.S. agricultural residue feedstock supplies. Industrial Biotechnology 6(5): 271-287. 2010.
Wortmann, C.S., R.N. Klein, and C.A. Shapiro. 2012. Harvesting crop residues. University of Nebraska-Lincoln Exten. NebGuide G1846 (revised).