SAES-422 Multistate Research Activity Accomplishments Report
Sections
Status: Approved
Basic Information
- Project No. and Title: W187 : Interactions Among Bark Beetles, Pathogens, and Conifers in North American Forests
- Period Covered: 01/01/2001 to 12/01/2001
- Date of Report: 06/03/2002
- Annual Meeting Dates: 10/12/2001 to 10/13/2001
Participants
Baker, Fred - Utah State University; Bentz, Barbara - USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station; Jacobi, Bill - Colorado State University; Negron, Jose - USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station; Ross, Darrell - Oregon State University; Seybold, Steven - University of Minnesota; Six, Diana - University of Montana; Bonello, P. Enrico - Ohio State University; Boone, Celia - University of Wisconsin; Cook, Steve - University of Idaho; Erbilgin, Nadir - University of California; McPherson, Brice - University of California; Schaffert, Danielle - Oregon State University; Stark, Dan - University of California; Sullivan, Brian - USDA Forest Service, Southern Research Station; Wallin, Kimberly - USDA Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station
Agenda item 1. Diana Six (Chair) welcomed all 16 attendees to the annual meeting of W-187 and thanked Darrell Ross for his excellent local arrangements. On day one, the agenda consisted of a discussion of business items followed by research reports. On day two, the agenda consisted of business matters including voting for new officers followed by additional research reports.
Agenda item 2. Chair Six brought a copy of the 2000 annual meeting minutes. Discussion ensued regarding the W-187 reporting format. Fred Baker suggested submitting two types of reports. The first would be a short report consisting of 3 or 4 bullet statements targeted toward a lay audience, particularly politicians. This report might include a list publications, extension presentations, fact sheets, and aspects of scientific progress that have immediate applied ramifications. The second is a longer, more scientifically-oriented report that could be posted on the web site. This report would list technical publications and be like a scientific abstract. Secretary Seybold will take the reports and organize information under the projects objective structure for the formal annual report.
Baker reported on status of the W-187 Web Site (http://cnr.usu.edu/departments/forest/w187-2/). The site currently has the project description and objectives, a PDF version of an Annual Review of Entomology article by Tim Paine and other project members, and the minutes and annual reports from 1999 and 2000. It also has a current membership list, an essay on who might join W-187, a copy of the Appendix E form, and a link to the current Chair. Baker asked whether the group should post a publication list relevant to the project and whether literature should be accessible and searchable in a database format. He also asked if we should post the individual publication lists of the PIs. As homepages of most PIs are accessible through the membership table on the web site, those lists are mostly already available; this suggestion was tabled. Seybold suggested that collaborative groups write summaries of their research projects for a lay audience and that the text be accompanied by graphics and illustrations. Baker asked members to send him slides or photographs to make the web site more visually appealing.
The committee then discussed W-187 renewal and steps that might be taken to enhance successful project continuation. The committee considered establishing collaborative contacts with other multistate research projects with similar interests. Two projects were identified: NCR-193 Plant Health: Managing Insects and Diseases of Landscape Plants, and W-189 Biorational Methods for Insect Pest Management (IPM): Bioorganic and Molecular Approaches. When renewal for W-187 was written in 1999, multistate project W-189 was identified as having the most potential overlap with W-187. Seybold is a member of both projects and Wood has attended annual meetings for both projects. W-187 members are more ecologically oriented and W-189 members are more chemically oriented, but members of both projects work on insect-plant interactions. Seybold noted that at their 2001annual meeting, W-189 members approved the idea of a joint meeting with W-187 and proposed that the meeting be held in Oct. 2002 in Taos, NM.
Baker suggested that the two projects share their project descriptions and progress reports with the respective memberships before the meeting. He suggested that it might be possible to write a paper or publishable summary as a result of the joint session. For the joint meeting to be a success, there should be more advance planning for the meeting than for a typical meeting and that the respective Chairs should consult frequently with one another before the joint meeting. Other ideas for the joint meeting included a 3-day meeting with one day of overlap between the projects; presentations during the overlapping period from each project on the development of each project; and research reports from each project on topics of interest to members of the other project. Members of W-187 with interested in chemical ecology should be encouraged to attend the joint meeting. Chair Six stressed that it would be important to complete this joint meeting in advance of the renewal of W-187. A vote was taken on the motion for a joint meeting with W-189 in Oct. 2002 in Taos; the motion passed unanimously. A joint meeting with NCR-193 will be contemplated at future annual meetings of W-187.
Chair Six suggested drafting of a new book summarizing the work of the scientists in W-187, which could be completed before the renewal of W-187. This would enhance renewal chances and provide a guidepost for the progress of the project since the 1993 book by Schowalter and Filip. Six planned to check on potential publishers and would e-mail her chapter suggestions/outline to the membership. She hoped to solicit chapter contributions from the membership. Items that came up during the discussion were: 1) the ultimate purchase price of the book (Six would work with the publisher to keep this low); 2) the content of the book--should the Schowalter and Filip text be revisited and updated or should a new approach be taken; and 3) the format of the book--should it be prepared as a digital book and made available on CD, which might keep the purchase price of the final product lower.
Another topic related to project revision was breadth of the project mission: should the project keep its focus on bark beetles, pathogens, and conifers or should it expand to include hardwood tree systems? With oak decline in California, continuing problems with oak wilt in eastern North America, and importance of hardwoods in urban/wildland interfaces, more scientists will be working on hardwood pathogen-bark beetle interactions; these scientists could join W-187. The project has been largely a western project, but there are some eastern scientists involved and others that could be more involved. It was noted that we are losing our representation of mycologists/Ophiostoma experts in the project; an effort should be made to recruit scientists working in this area. Ross wondered if there would be a disadvantage to broadening the project; we should contact Administrative Advisor Daugherty and see if whether broadening the focus too much would hurt the project. Jacobi noted that there may be too few of us and that the project should be expanded nationally. He said we should call people and invite them to attend the annual meeting. McPherson reported that the mechanism is flawed for announcing the annual meeting to participants who are not committee members. For example, he is not on the e-mail list and did not receive information about this meeting until it was passed on to him by Wood. Baker agreed to construct an unofficial section on the web site that will always have a current list of cooperators and collaborators who are not official members of the project. Ross suggested that the philosophy of the group has always been to advertise the meeting as widely as possible to attract as much interest as possible, and this years attendees agreed with this approach. Returning to the breadth of the project mission, Seybold noted that the theme is insect/pathogen/tree interactions and that if we broaden the mission to include hardwoods then we have to be careful not to overlap with NCR-193 (insects/pathogens on woody ornamentals), which involves ornamental hardwoods. Chair Six pointed out that the focus of W-187 is on bark beetles and if we keep that focus and expand to other host trees, the project will still be unique. The consensus was that we should expand the project now in preparation for the renewal to enhance the vitality of the project. New content on hardwoods could be incorporated into the renewed proposal in 2003.
Discussion of new officers for 2001-2002 led to the nomination of Steve Seybold to Chair W-187 and to coordinate the joint meeting with W-189 in Oct. 2002. Steve Cook was nominated to serve as Secretary in 2001-2002 and to lead the renewal effort of the proposal as Chair in 2002-2003.
Agenda item 3. The Administrative Advisor was absent due to other obligations. The CSREES advisor also was absent, but he sent Chair Six information on national activities. First, there was concern in Washington that long-term funding for USDA, NSF, and other agencies may be in jeopardy due to terrorist attacks of Sept. 11. Second, FY 2001 and 2002 funding was secure because the Congress had passed a continuing resolution and President Bush had signed the resolution. Third, there is a personnel change with the USDA Biologically Based Pest Management Grant Program. Bob Nowierski from Montana State University had just been named to head the program. The group concluded that, given his past record of activity on behalf of W-187, Dr. Daughertys absence from the meeting was no reflection on his support for or interest in the project.
Agenda item 4. Chair Six asked that everyone in attendance give a brief introduction of themselves including their affiliation and area of interest. Bentz announced the WFIWC Scholarship for graduate students. Deadline is Jan. 15, 2002, and the application is available on the WFIWC web site. Ross announced the Norman R. DuBois scholarship for biocontrol (ESA) and Six announced the Jeffrey LaFage scholarship for termite biology (ESA). Applications were encouraged for these awards.
Agenda item 5. The committee reaffirmed that the next annual meeting would be held in October 2002 in Taos, NM. The date would be determined by the respective Chairs of W-187 and W-189.
Agenda item 6. The group brainstormed about scientific products related to the research presented during the meeting. The following list of examples was generated with no particular order to the topics. A logistic regression model has been developed to estimate the probability of infestation at the stand and tree levels for pinyon ips, Ips confusus, in pinyon pine, Pinus edulis, in Arizona (Negrsn). Douglas-fir beetle aggregation pheromone might be used by resource managers who are interested in the possibility of selectively killing dwarf mistletoe-infected trees (Ross). Forest thinning or a combination of thinning and fire might be used as techniques to ensure forest succession and diversity and prevent major conflagrations (Wood). Systemic induced resistance is a basic mechanism in pines that could be enhanced and utilized to prevent disease and create more healthy trees (Bonello). Areas of high risk to pines for mountain pine beetle attack can be detected based on changes in spectral resolution at 30 m spatial resolution (Landsat) and potentially at 3.5 m spatial resolution (AVIRIS-NASA). The latter resolution may allow resource managers to detect infestations at the level of 1 or 2 trees while they are still manageable (Cook).
Next Meeting Information: Location and Date: Taos, NM, October 2002. Responsible Individuals: Steve Seybold, University of Minnesota (Chair Elect), LeRoy Daugherty (Administrative Advisor), Diana Six, University of Montana (Local Arrangements Coordinator and ex-Chair), and Steve Cook, University of Idaho (Secretary).
Between Meeting Information Exchange/Development Information: It was suggested that we communicate electronically to assemble the annual report with a focus on impacts and outcomes. Further, development of the W-187 web site through Baker was encouraged. An emphasis on joint publications and joint grants was encouraged so as to have higher impacts in the future.