
NE2603: Advancing high tunnel specialty crop production
(Multistate Research Project)
Status: Active
Homepage
High tunnels are portable, greenhouse-like structures with a single or double layer of plastic, with or without supplemental heat, power, or mechanical ventilation, with crops usually grown in-ground (Wells and Loy, 1993). High tunnels increase the length of the growing season, yield, fruit quality, and nutrient uptake efficiency, and provide some climactic control compared to field production (Reeve and Drost, 2012) at lower expense than heated greenhouses. High tunnel production became widespread in the 1990s and has increased dramatically in recent years as federal conservation initiatives through the U.S. Department of Agriculture Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) incentivized installation of new tunnels beginning in 2009. For example, between 2017-2020, over 2000 contracts for high tunnels were awarded annually through the NRCS high tunnel initiative (Donovan et al., 2023). High tunnels funded by NRCS have specific requirements that set them apart from other protected culture practices (e.g., low tunnels, some caterpillar tunnels, and soilless hydroponic systems): 1) crops must be grown in natural soil although up to 12 inch (depth) raised beds are allowed, 2) the high tunnel must stand 6 ft tall or higher, 3) the maximum size allowed is 2,160 ft2, and 4) tunnels must be built from pre-approved kits (no DIY designs allowed). Heating/cooling units or electricity is not covered by NRCS funding, but growers can install these tools on their own. This style of high tunnel dominates protected culture in the U.S., so this project will focus on developing innovative pest, soil, and climate control tools tailored to these systems.
High tunnels are typically used to lengthen the growing season for warm-season crops such as tomato, eggplant, pepper, and cucurbits (Carey et al., 2009; Fitzgerald and Hutton, 2012; Knewtson et al., 2010; Lamont, 2009; O’Connell et al., 2012; Gong et al., 2022). High tunnels also permit growers in colder climates to grow crops during times when it would otherwise not be possible, and to grow perennial crops that could not be grown in the region otherwise, thereby increasing market opportunities (Fitzgerald and Hutton 2012, Sideman unpublished data). Several studies have shown that high tunnels confer yield and quality benefits (Frey et al., 2020, O’Connell et al., 2012, and many others). In addition to increasing economic stability and earnings, farmers report better yields, easier management of some pests and diseases, and an increased quality of life when using high tunnels on their farms (Bruce et al. 2019a, 2019b).
Several regional surveys of high tunnel producers and extension professionals have identified benefits and advantages of using high tunnels, as well as challenges that define research and educational needs (Fitzgerald and Hutton 2012, Foust-Meyer and O-Rourke 2015, Bruce et al. 2019b, Sideman et al. unpublished; Nian et al. 2025). The protected environment created by high tunnels not only alters crop growth as compared with open field conditions, but also modifies soil moisture dynamics, nutrient mineralization and leaching, the environmental suitability for pest and disease development, and behavior of pathogens and both pest and non-pest organisms including natural enemies and pollinators. With their small area and high land value, high tunnel soils are often managed intensively, with heavy (and possibly excessive) inputs of fertilizer and other amendments. The many differences between high tunnel and open field production necessitate the use of crop varieties, entire production systems, and pest and disease management strategies unique to high tunnels. Management challenges also exist, such as increased labor and time requirements and increased complexity of high tunnel production (Bruce et al., 2019b). Thus, several research and outreach priorities and challenges are specific to high tunnel systems. While there are certainly regional differences, many of the high-priority challenges related to high tunnel production are common to producers across a wide geographic area.
According to Lamont (2009), the U.S. had approximately 5,000 ha of high tunnels and greenhouses combined at that time. In 2010, the USDA-NRCS began to incentivize new high tunnel installations; 9,489 high tunnels (representing at least 176 ha) were added throughout the U.S. between Jan 2010 and Dec 2013 alone (Foust-Meyer and O-Rourke 2015). However, despite increasing prevalence of high tunnels, we don’t have accurate data about how many high tunnels are in operation throughout the U.S. or about their economic importance to small- and mid-sized farms. The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s National Agricultural Statistics Service (NASS) groups all protected cultivation (high-tech greenhouses and low-tech high tunnels) together. Estimates obtained through an informal survey conducted by Carey et al (2009) were highly variable, and high tunnel definitions were not consistent.
Myriad research and extension activities related to high tunnel production are taking place across the U.S. However, due to the broad geographic dispersal of high tunnel research and extension personnel, a forum to promote coordination and collaboration is needed to support multi-state, multi-institutional, and cross-disciplinary approaches to solve common problems.
In 2020, the multistate coordinating committee NECC-2103 High tunnel specialty crop production, was formed. The purpose of this coordinating committee was to facilitate collaboration across states to: 1) characterize the high tunnel ‘landscape’, e.g., to quantify high tunnel acreage and production systems, 2) research pests and diseases unique to high tunnel production systems, 3) determine adaptability of new cultivars to high tunnel production systems, 4) research strategies to optimize soil, nutrient, water, temperature, and crop management in high tunnels, and 5) share research plans to avoid duplication and inefficient use of resources, and to foster multi-institutional and cross-disciplinary research.
Since inception, this committee has met regularly and has built its membership steadily; NECC 2103 currently has 28 members from 16 states. Over the last year, the coordinating committee officers met and discussed with membership whether to continue as a coordinating committee, or to instead propose a multi-state research proposal. We decided to move forward with a proposal to create a multistate research project focused on Advancing high tunnel specialty crop production. Since the inception of NECC 2103, the number of faculty and extension educators in CEA has increased across the U.S., further justifying the need for this multistate project.